*****
By City of Angels Lady
The more Church Attorneys have to talk in court, the better things go for plaintiffs, as even in today’s slow grind of justice, the truth inevitably comes out. At a June 6 hearing, the judge denied plaintiff’s request for a protective order, and in the same case, denied the church’s attempt to prevent deposition of a witness, and no matter what defendants argued, the plaintiffs’ cases kept shining through.
To show how compassionate a man Clinton Hagenbach really is, a Church Attorney told the judge, “A letter was sent to all the members of the parish” about the same time period as the calendar entry about which plaintiffs want to question this witness. The female Church Attorney beside him chimed in, “He (Hagenbach) was upset to be leaving because he had so many dear friends in the families at that parish.”
Plaintiff liaison Tony DeMarco jumped up and said, “Your Honor that letter is something we’d like to see.”
Then in yesterday’s hearings Church Attorney Sean Kneafsey assured Katherine Freberg in front of the judge: “The bulletins are being copied as we speak.” So more evidence is piling up in preparation for the Hagenbach Cases Jury Trial now set for July 9th.
“THOSE DOCUMENTS Should have been produced a year and a half ago” -- Katherine Freberg
Yesterday in court Katherine Freberg went on the record again about how difficult it’s been to get the LA Archdiocese to cooperate with pretrial discovery.
“At this point what we need is an order with a time deadline to force the defendants to turn over this discovery within the time limit,” Freberg stated. “The problem is we get agreement from defendants to produce but with no court order. . .”
*****Commercial Break*****
About the only place to find an honest and free press in America today is in blogs. Please help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five on the Pay-Pal Account (click the button top left corner). I report your support to the IRS as freelance income so everything is above board.
We don’t want to have to rely on mainstream media. . .unless Paris Hilton is a survivor, we'll never get the story.
END COMMERCIAL BREAK**********
Back to June 13th hearing:
As Church Attorneys have said many times before in front of the judge, “We’ve agreed to produce the documents.” They tend to agree to agree to do it, but never get around to doing it. It’s the same legal word-mangling that made it true when Bill Clinton said, “I never had sexual relations with that woman.”
“The defendants are now producing documents that should have been produced a year and a half ago,” Freberg said on the record in court.
------------------
That Elusive Hearing On Cardinal Mahony’s Answers To Interrogatories Is Back On Calendar.
Remember Cardinal Mahony’s non answers, the hearing that disappeared from the calendar then reappeared then disappeared on May 30th? Freberg has been trying to get definitive answers to Interrogatories 1 through 8 from Cardinal Mahony since August 2005. The answer that Mahony finally gave to almost every answer after a year was:
“Responding party objects to this request. It’s broad, burdensome, harassing, not relevant. Violates religion clause of First Amendment, physician patient privilege, lawyer client privilege, and work product doctrine.”
Today’s calendar at LA Superior Court Website has this hearing set for Wednesday June 20th: “MOTION - COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES (TO INTERROGATORIES 1-8(PAPERS FILED ON 4/12)**CONT FROM 5/30**RE: BC307225)”
If I’m not mistaken that hearing was not posted at the Superior Court website on the calendar yesterday. It just appeared there again, as of this morning. Pay attention, it may disappear again.
*****Commercial Break*****
About the only place to find an honest and free press in America today is in blogs. Please help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five on the Pay-Pal Account. I report your support to the IRS as freelance income so everything is above board.
We don’t want to have to rely on mainstream media. . .unless Madonna is a survivor, we'll never get the story.
END COMMERCIAL BREAK**********
A SUBPOENA CAN BE SO DISTRACTING
How is a Church Attorney supposed to Keep Track?
When the hearing on Mahony’s answers to Interrogatories 1 through 8 disappeared from the calendar on May 30th word was that since the Cardinal had been served with a subpoena the week before he and his seven to eight law firms were too busy fighting to keep him from having to testify and they just forgot about the hearing about answering written interrogatories.
Freberg gave another possible reason for the disappearing hearing on Interrogatories 1 through 8 May 30th when she explained, “these things happen.” She’d filed several motions in one day.
It’s easy to see how out of the thousands of motions filed with no problem since last fall in these cases, the one about Mahony’s response to interrogatories just accidentally got totally mishandled, mis-scheduled, mislabeled, and although she was the filing attorney, Freberg didn't know about the latest changes to the calendar.
However no church attorneys showed up for the non-scheduled hearing, so someone must have let them know in advance. . . .
Now the hearing on Interrogatories 1 through 8 is on again for Wednesday June 20th, it’s on the LA Superior Court website/civil under Case Summaries (type in JCCP4286 as case number).
*****Commercial Break*****
About the only place to find an honest and free press in America today is in blogs. Please help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five on the Pay-Pal Account. I report your support to the IRS as freelance income so everything is above board.
We don’t want to have to rely on mainstream media. . .unless an American Idol contestant is a survivor, we'll never get the story.
END COMMERCIAL BREAK
**********
MORE ON HAGENBACH PRETRIAL HEARINGS:
In the order June 6th denying a protective order, even though plaintiff’s attorney stated, “There is evidence corroborated by the mother that (plaintiff) has an extreme fear of bodily injury or death if this employer is brought back into his life,” the church argued that they were having trouble finding any other employer of this plaintiff to interview.
Ironically, that's exactly why so many of us become plaintiffs. The damage from being raped by a priest is so devastating many of us haven’t been able to hold down jobs.
So defendants once again find themselves arguing for the plaintiffs, as Church Attorneys get tangled up in their contradictory objections, twisting one weird response into another and you know what? In the end the truth comes out.
From the church fighting the plaintiff’s protective order:
CHURCH ATTORNEY KNEAFSEY: Um, your honor, Mr. (SAYS PLAINTIFF’S NAME. IT’S ALWAYS A CHURCH ATTORNEY WHO SAYS THE PLAINTIFf’S NAME OUT LOUD AND CLEAR IN COURT.) has been operating under the radar for years. We haven’t been able to find any employment history. This is the only employer we've been able to find we and need to question him.
CHURCH ATTORNEY KNEAFSEY CONT’D: Mr. --- testified that he’s not been able to hold down any job for no other reason than abuse by Hagenbach. We haven’t found anything to substantiate that.
JUDGE: This employment was for two months in 1987. . . . It’s a very thin story that’s proffered and it’s insufficient so the tentative (denying the motion) will be the order.
*****Commercial Break*****
About the only place to find an honest and free press in America today is in blogs. Please help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five on the Pay-Pal Account. I report your support to the IRS as freelance income so everything is above board.
We don’t want to have to rely on mainstream media. . .unless Hillary Clinton is a survivor, we'll never get the story.
END COMMERCIAL BREAK
**********
More to Come. . .
Thursday, June 14, 2007
Tuesday, June 12, 2007
Church Attorneys try to get Report to People of God thrown out as well as quash Mahony’s testimony. “Motion is denied” -- quotes from Judge's order
*****
That his testimony might be inflammatory appears to be unavoidable. -- Judge Fromholz
By City of Angels Lady
Here are quotes from Judge Haley Fromholz’ order denying the church’s “Motion of Defendant Does 1 and 2 for an Order Quashing Civil Subpoena” dated June 6. . . issued to Cardinal Roger Michael Mahony.
“Plaintiff has issued a Civil Subpoena (Duces Tecum) for the personal appearance and production of documents and things to Cardinal Mahony. Defendants argue that good cause exists to quash the subpoena”
"Motion is denied"
"Defendants first argue that the subpoena is oppressive because Plaintiff has not conducted Cardinal Mahony’s deposition and there is therefore “no way of knowing what areas of inquiry or line of questioning Plaintiff’s counsel will delve into in order to determine whether it is admissible.” [Motion 2:12-14]. Defendants predict that it will consequently be necessary to object to every question that is asked, and that this will prejudice defense counsel in the eyes of the jury. [Id. 2:13-16]. . . . .
That his testimony might be “inflammatory” appears to be “unavoidable.”
“Inconceivable that notice of abuse could be relevant” argue Church Attorneys - denied.
“Defendant argues that it is inconceivable that notice of abuse by other individuals to other entities could be relevant to show that Defendant exhibited conscious disregard in this case. . . .
“Defendant argues that Weeks demonstrates that notice must be to the same defendant that received notice in the other instances.
“The Defendant in this case is the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Los Angeles, the same Defendant may have received notice in other cases.”
The Court finds that the risk of prejudice from Defense counsel’s objections is not high enough, and the prejudice not severe enough, to warrant exclusion of evidence under §352. To the extent that Defendant is arguing that the testimony might be “inflammatory,” [see Motion 2:24] this would appear to be unavoidable, to some extent, given the nature of the case.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) Just about the only place to find an honest and free press in America today is in blogs.
So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner and pay whatever you want to support reporting on LA Clergy Cases 2007. The money goes directly to the writer of this blog who reports it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
You'll be keeping alive an American tradition: passing the hat. If 350 people send me five dollars each month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
Otherwise I’ll have to get a real job. And we’ll all have to rely on mainstream media. . .
END COMMERCIAL BREAK
**********
“Indeed, Cardinal Mahony appears to be the head of the defendant corporation sole,” writes Fromholz
Mahony Not a percipient Witness -- Denied
“Defendant also argues that Cardinal Mahony is not a percipient witness to any of the allegations or facts in this action because he did not become affiliated with the Los Angeles Archdiocese until the mid-1980s. [Id. 2:18-21].
"However, Plaintiff argues that Cardinal Mahony’s testimony may be relevant in interpreting the Report to the People of God, discussed below, and may also be relevant with respect to corporate practices.
“Indeed, Cardinal Mahony appears to be the head of the defendant corporation sole.
“The Court finds insufficient good cause to quash the subpoena."
Church Attorneys Can’t Get The Report to the People of God ordered “irrelevant” as evidence.
“Defendant argues that the Report to the People of God (“Report”) is irrelevant.
“The evidence might also be relevant to a determination of whether punitive damages are warranted, since it could go to show conscious disregard under Civil Code §3294(b).
More on Report to People of God as Church tries to say it’s “inadmissible”
Plaintiff also argues that the Report is admissible under Evidence Code §1105, which states that “[a]ny otherwise admissible evidence of habit or custom is admissible to prove conduct on a specified occasion in conformity with the habit or custom.”
“Custom,” meaning the routine practice or behavior on the part of a group or organization that is equivalent to the habit of an individual, is often established by evidence of repeated instances of similar conduct. People v. Memro (1985) 38 Cal.3d 658.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) Just about the only place to find an honest and free press in America today is in blogs.
So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner and pay whatever you want to support reporting on LA Clergy Cases 2007. The money goes directly to the writer of this blog who reports it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
You'll be keeping alive an American tradition: passing the hat. If 350 people send me five dollars each month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
Otherwise I’ll have to get a real job. And we’ll all have to rely on mainstream media. . .
END COMMERCIAL BREAK
“Report to People of God” is “hearsay” per Church Attorneys
Fromholz Order re Mahony testimony Continued:
“Defendant next argues that the Report is hearsay. . . .
“Plaintiff states that the Report was signed by Cardinal Mahony and posted on the Archdiocese’s official website. [Opp. 1:28-2:2].
Transfering Perps could be relevant information
“If Plaintiff is able to establish that Defendant had a pattern or practice of concealing abuse and moving perpetrators from school to school, this information could be relevant. . . .”
Defendant appears to concede the point that there is evidence of conduct showing “that a person committed a crime, civil wrong, or other act.”
. . .
“Evidence of concealment and reassignment in other cases could well be relevant”
“Evidence of concealment and reassignment in other cases could well be relevant to show that Defendant followed a similar course of conduct, or plan, in the instant case. This evidence could be relevant, for example, to show that Defendant did not ‘take reasonable steps . . . to implement reasonable safeguards to avoid acts of unlawful sexual conduct.’. . . .
"Even if Defendant’s arguments were persuasive,
the Court finds that questions as to relevance and admissibility are better reserved for trial."
Dated: June 6, 2007
HALEY J. FROMHOLZ
JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT”
So my job today is easy. Just run the order as signed by the judge. Good day to lie in the sun. . . .
Four Hearings Wednesday June 13th
As posted at LA Superior Court Website under Case Summaries for #JCCP4286
All at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion to Compel (- FOR ADMISSIONS- FOR DOCUMENTS- FOR DOCUMENTS, SET TWO- STANDARDIZED INTERROGATORIES**CONT FROM 5/30**RE: BC308294)
DEMURRER (TO COMPLAINT(PAPERS FILED ON 5/03)RE: BC307672)
Motion for Reconsideration (OF RULINGS(PAPERS FILED ON 5/03)RE: BC308621)
MOTION - COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES ((PAPERS FILED ON 6/06))
And City of Angels Lady will be there, even if no one clicks my button and puts money on the Pay-Pal account. But it’d be easier if I wasn’t worrying about July rent. The transcription work I was doing is still disappeared.
More to Come. . .
That his testimony might be inflammatory appears to be unavoidable. -- Judge Fromholz
By City of Angels Lady
Here are quotes from Judge Haley Fromholz’ order denying the church’s “Motion of Defendant Does 1 and 2 for an Order Quashing Civil Subpoena” dated June 6. . . issued to Cardinal Roger Michael Mahony.
“Plaintiff has issued a Civil Subpoena (Duces Tecum) for the personal appearance and production of documents and things to Cardinal Mahony. Defendants argue that good cause exists to quash the subpoena”
"Motion is denied"
"Defendants first argue that the subpoena is oppressive because Plaintiff has not conducted Cardinal Mahony’s deposition and there is therefore “no way of knowing what areas of inquiry or line of questioning Plaintiff’s counsel will delve into in order to determine whether it is admissible.” [Motion 2:12-14]. Defendants predict that it will consequently be necessary to object to every question that is asked, and that this will prejudice defense counsel in the eyes of the jury. [Id. 2:13-16]. . . . .
That his testimony might be “inflammatory” appears to be “unavoidable.”
“Inconceivable that notice of abuse could be relevant” argue Church Attorneys - denied.
“Defendant argues that it is inconceivable that notice of abuse by other individuals to other entities could be relevant to show that Defendant exhibited conscious disregard in this case. . . .
“Defendant argues that Weeks demonstrates that notice must be to the same defendant that received notice in the other instances.
“The Defendant in this case is the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Los Angeles, the same Defendant may have received notice in other cases.”
The Court finds that the risk of prejudice from Defense counsel’s objections is not high enough, and the prejudice not severe enough, to warrant exclusion of evidence under §352. To the extent that Defendant is arguing that the testimony might be “inflammatory,” [see Motion 2:24] this would appear to be unavoidable, to some extent, given the nature of the case.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) Just about the only place to find an honest and free press in America today is in blogs.
So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner and pay whatever you want to support reporting on LA Clergy Cases 2007. The money goes directly to the writer of this blog who reports it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
You'll be keeping alive an American tradition: passing the hat. If 350 people send me five dollars each month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
Otherwise I’ll have to get a real job. And we’ll all have to rely on mainstream media. . .
END COMMERCIAL BREAK
**********
“Indeed, Cardinal Mahony appears to be the head of the defendant corporation sole,” writes Fromholz
Mahony Not a percipient Witness -- Denied
“Defendant also argues that Cardinal Mahony is not a percipient witness to any of the allegations or facts in this action because he did not become affiliated with the Los Angeles Archdiocese until the mid-1980s. [Id. 2:18-21].
"However, Plaintiff argues that Cardinal Mahony’s testimony may be relevant in interpreting the Report to the People of God, discussed below, and may also be relevant with respect to corporate practices.
“Indeed, Cardinal Mahony appears to be the head of the defendant corporation sole.
“The Court finds insufficient good cause to quash the subpoena."
Church Attorneys Can’t Get The Report to the People of God ordered “irrelevant” as evidence.
“Defendant argues that the Report to the People of God (“Report”) is irrelevant.
“The evidence might also be relevant to a determination of whether punitive damages are warranted, since it could go to show conscious disregard under Civil Code §3294(b).
More on Report to People of God as Church tries to say it’s “inadmissible”
Plaintiff also argues that the Report is admissible under Evidence Code §1105, which states that “[a]ny otherwise admissible evidence of habit or custom is admissible to prove conduct on a specified occasion in conformity with the habit or custom.”
“Custom,” meaning the routine practice or behavior on the part of a group or organization that is equivalent to the habit of an individual, is often established by evidence of repeated instances of similar conduct. People v. Memro (1985) 38 Cal.3d 658.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) Just about the only place to find an honest and free press in America today is in blogs.
So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner and pay whatever you want to support reporting on LA Clergy Cases 2007. The money goes directly to the writer of this blog who reports it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
You'll be keeping alive an American tradition: passing the hat. If 350 people send me five dollars each month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
Otherwise I’ll have to get a real job. And we’ll all have to rely on mainstream media. . .
END COMMERCIAL BREAK
“Report to People of God” is “hearsay” per Church Attorneys
Fromholz Order re Mahony testimony Continued:
“Defendant next argues that the Report is hearsay. . . .
“Plaintiff states that the Report was signed by Cardinal Mahony and posted on the Archdiocese’s official website. [Opp. 1:28-2:2].
Transfering Perps could be relevant information
“If Plaintiff is able to establish that Defendant had a pattern or practice of concealing abuse and moving perpetrators from school to school, this information could be relevant. . . .”
Defendant appears to concede the point that there is evidence of conduct showing “that a person committed a crime, civil wrong, or other act.”
. . .
“Evidence of concealment and reassignment in other cases could well be relevant”
“Evidence of concealment and reassignment in other cases could well be relevant to show that Defendant followed a similar course of conduct, or plan, in the instant case. This evidence could be relevant, for example, to show that Defendant did not ‘take reasonable steps . . . to implement reasonable safeguards to avoid acts of unlawful sexual conduct.’. . . .
"Even if Defendant’s arguments were persuasive,
the Court finds that questions as to relevance and admissibility are better reserved for trial."
Dated: June 6, 2007
HALEY J. FROMHOLZ
JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT”
So my job today is easy. Just run the order as signed by the judge. Good day to lie in the sun. . . .
Four Hearings Wednesday June 13th
As posted at LA Superior Court Website under Case Summaries for #JCCP4286
All at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion to Compel (- FOR ADMISSIONS- FOR DOCUMENTS- FOR DOCUMENTS, SET TWO- STANDARDIZED INTERROGATORIES**CONT FROM 5/30**RE: BC308294)
DEMURRER (TO COMPLAINT(PAPERS FILED ON 5/03)RE: BC307672)
Motion for Reconsideration (OF RULINGS(PAPERS FILED ON 5/03)RE: BC308621)
MOTION - COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES ((PAPERS FILED ON 6/06))
And City of Angels Lady will be there, even if no one clicks my button and puts money on the Pay-Pal account. But it’d be easier if I wasn’t worrying about July rent. The transcription work I was doing is still disappeared.
More to Come. . .
Thursday, June 7, 2007
More Orders Re Mahony’s Testimony Coming Monday; Kreutzer Jury Trial Continued to August 6th, PLUS, Hundreds of Documents Disappear from Public Access
***
By City of Angels Lady
Judge Haley Fromholz cleared a hurdle for Cardinal Roger Mahony’s testimony in upcoming civil trials in LA, by denying the church’s Motion for Order Quashing Civil Subpoena filed for a Kreutzer case. Then half hour later, Fromholz granted the church’s request to postpone the first jury trial where Mahony is to testify, from June 11th to August 6th. The judge emphasized this is not the first ruling regarding the archbishop.
JUDGE: My rulings here were all tentative. I intend to rule on them, uh, un-tentatively on Monday. (leans forward and asserts) I will rule with fervor and authority on Monday on particular documents, questions to be asked, whether a proffer is needed.
Steven J. Brady, Plaintiff Attorney from San Francisco who subpoenaed the archbishop sat at the table while three church attorneys Phil Baker, Bob Baker, and Michael Hennigan, stood for the defendants at his left. Brady’s voice emitted surprising authority:
BRADY: I still expect him to appear at trial.
The three church attorneys each shift weight on their feet. Two of them button their suitcoats.
At the hearing re rescheduling the first trial, even though Brady argued: “There are no new claims that need to be defended in the second amended complaint. It’s simply prepare for punitive damages,” the judge went along with the church’s argument:
CHURCH ATTORNEY PHILLIP BAKER: Their second amended complaint filed yesterday now needs to be responded to. They're raising issues like vicarious responsibility.
Vicarious Responsibility??? -
To me, the church is acting like this is the first they've heard of Sister Frances Catherine.
(I really don’t get this. I’ve read about Sister Frances Catherine in numerous documents regarding the Paul Kreutzer cases. Still the judge granted the continuance.)
BAKER Cont’d: There was no allegation against Sister Frances. Now there’s this new brief they've filed “willy nilly” on Monday. And we have to respond to them, whether or not they can seek discovery about what Sister Frances Catherine did. It’ll affect jury selection. When did she engage with Ms. Buser? This will have to be briefed to you.
JUDGE: I’m inclined to grant a short continuance.
Now the first Kreutzer case is August 6th, and the first jury trial in LA Clergy Cases 2007 is July 9th, the Hagenbach cases.
========
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) Just about the only place to find an honest and free press in America today is in blogs.
So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner and pay whatever you want to support reporting on LA Clergy Cases 2007. The money goes directly to the writer of this blog who reports it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
You'll be keeping alive an American tradition: passing the hat. If 350 people send me five dollars each month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
Otherwise I’ll have to get a real job. And we’ll all have to rely on mainstream media. . .
END COMMERCIAL BREAK
**********
KREUTZER CASE JURY TRIAL CONTINUED
Continued. . .
Steven Brady the plaintiff attorney from San Francisco seemed a bit taken aback Wednesday, first as Judge Fromholz postponed a definitive order regarding Mahony and then later when he agreed to delay the Kreutzer case jury trial:
JUDGE FROMHOLZ: Mr. Brady, when you make a motion to add punitive damages there are sometimes consequences. I think it’s in everybody’s interest not to be inclined to do something here that will plant a time bomb and basis for appeal. An order declining a continuance at the beginning of a case can be an issue.
JUDGE: Cont’d: So that's what I’m inclined to do but it will be a short continuance.
BRADY: Let me just tell you this whole issue of which damages are recoverable was raised by defendants at settlement conference --
JUDGE: I asked you earlier if you had anything to bring up. You can’t bring it up now.
Lead Church Attorney Hennigan suggests that since the other Kreutzer cases, with the same plaintiff attorney, are on calendar for jury trial in November, maybe we could combine them all then?
TONY DEMARCO: More than a year ago it was defense counsel that selected a portion of the Kreutzer cases for earlier trial. That was with the contemplation that these first cases would go forward.
BRADY: I don't think the continuance is appropriate. There are no new issues for the defense. It allows them to test waters in other matters. They've filed this Hail Mary Motion on the eve of trial. I mean in this case it takes the heat off the defense.
Judge Fromholz gets out his calendar and the Kreutzer case jury trial, five days before it’s scheduled to begin, slips to August 6th.
======
EXTRA! EXTRA!
======
HUNDREDS OF DOCUMENTS HAVE DISAPPEARED FROM THE SUPERIOR COURT NETWORK“300 plus screens, pages and pages.” There it is in my April 3rd notes. So. . .
On April 3rd there were more than 300 screens of document names that link you to view the document, in the LA civil cases against the Catholic Church. Thursday a woman from the Court’s Public Information Office straightened me out on the “non-access to documents” problem.
“You just go forward starting from Document One, which won’t take that long,” she said.
I argued, No there are like 30,000 screens.
She went forward 10 screens at a time and there at screen 172 she was at a document filed June 4, 2007. I was humbled, apologized. I was sure there had been more screens than that.
THERE WERE MORE THAN 300 SCREENS THAN THAT
ON APRIL 3rd.
NOW THERE ARE ONLY 172 SCREENS LINKING TO DOCUMENTS
What happened to more than half the Clergy Case Documents?
In my notes April 3rd I remark that I’m on Screen 300 something. I estimated about 30 document names per screen, average. Okay 30,000 screens was a little off, but there are now less than half as many screens linking to documents as there were in April, and hundreds of documents have been filed in the 550 cases since last April.
There were more than 300 screens of documents in April. Now there are 172.
DO YOU UNDERSTAND THE WORDS THAT ARE COMING FROM MY LAPTOP???
Someone has removed more than half the documents from public access in the Clergy Cases.
Someone, maybe from both the church and plaintiffs sides, maybe even the judge, has removed more than half the documents that used to be available for the public to read in the ArcScanWeb network which maintains the Clergy Case files for LA Superior Court. (Private outsourced software contractor. . . .) (Who is paying attention to them?)
This comes directly after the “upgrade” by a private software firm on the Clergy Case JCCP documents section of the LA Superior Court network on May 31, last Thursday.
As of June 6th there are now only 172 screens. At least half the documents in the LA Clergy Cases 2007 have disappeared from the public access screens, both at the website and in Room 106 of Superior Court.
=====
The other hearings Wednesday covered a motion for protective order filed by a plaintiff (Denied) and a Motion to Compel a Non-Party to Comply with Deposition filed by Plaintiff (Granted). Next post will be a report on those two hearings. Both concern Hagenbach cases, now scheduled for jury trial July 9th.
More to come. . .
By City of Angels Lady
Judge Haley Fromholz cleared a hurdle for Cardinal Roger Mahony’s testimony in upcoming civil trials in LA, by denying the church’s Motion for Order Quashing Civil Subpoena filed for a Kreutzer case. Then half hour later, Fromholz granted the church’s request to postpone the first jury trial where Mahony is to testify, from June 11th to August 6th. The judge emphasized this is not the first ruling regarding the archbishop.
JUDGE: My rulings here were all tentative. I intend to rule on them, uh, un-tentatively on Monday. (leans forward and asserts) I will rule with fervor and authority on Monday on particular documents, questions to be asked, whether a proffer is needed.
Steven J. Brady, Plaintiff Attorney from San Francisco who subpoenaed the archbishop sat at the table while three church attorneys Phil Baker, Bob Baker, and Michael Hennigan, stood for the defendants at his left. Brady’s voice emitted surprising authority:
BRADY: I still expect him to appear at trial.
The three church attorneys each shift weight on their feet. Two of them button their suitcoats.
At the hearing re rescheduling the first trial, even though Brady argued: “There are no new claims that need to be defended in the second amended complaint. It’s simply prepare for punitive damages,” the judge went along with the church’s argument:
CHURCH ATTORNEY PHILLIP BAKER: Their second amended complaint filed yesterday now needs to be responded to. They're raising issues like vicarious responsibility.
Vicarious Responsibility??? -
To me, the church is acting like this is the first they've heard of Sister Frances Catherine.
(I really don’t get this. I’ve read about Sister Frances Catherine in numerous documents regarding the Paul Kreutzer cases. Still the judge granted the continuance.)
BAKER Cont’d: There was no allegation against Sister Frances. Now there’s this new brief they've filed “willy nilly” on Monday. And we have to respond to them, whether or not they can seek discovery about what Sister Frances Catherine did. It’ll affect jury selection. When did she engage with Ms. Buser? This will have to be briefed to you.
JUDGE: I’m inclined to grant a short continuance.
Now the first Kreutzer case is August 6th, and the first jury trial in LA Clergy Cases 2007 is July 9th, the Hagenbach cases.
========
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) Just about the only place to find an honest and free press in America today is in blogs.
So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner and pay whatever you want to support reporting on LA Clergy Cases 2007. The money goes directly to the writer of this blog who reports it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
You'll be keeping alive an American tradition: passing the hat. If 350 people send me five dollars each month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
Otherwise I’ll have to get a real job. And we’ll all have to rely on mainstream media. . .
END COMMERCIAL BREAK
**********
KREUTZER CASE JURY TRIAL CONTINUED
Continued. . .
Steven Brady the plaintiff attorney from San Francisco seemed a bit taken aback Wednesday, first as Judge Fromholz postponed a definitive order regarding Mahony and then later when he agreed to delay the Kreutzer case jury trial:
JUDGE FROMHOLZ: Mr. Brady, when you make a motion to add punitive damages there are sometimes consequences. I think it’s in everybody’s interest not to be inclined to do something here that will plant a time bomb and basis for appeal. An order declining a continuance at the beginning of a case can be an issue.
JUDGE: Cont’d: So that's what I’m inclined to do but it will be a short continuance.
BRADY: Let me just tell you this whole issue of which damages are recoverable was raised by defendants at settlement conference --
JUDGE: I asked you earlier if you had anything to bring up. You can’t bring it up now.
Lead Church Attorney Hennigan suggests that since the other Kreutzer cases, with the same plaintiff attorney, are on calendar for jury trial in November, maybe we could combine them all then?
TONY DEMARCO: More than a year ago it was defense counsel that selected a portion of the Kreutzer cases for earlier trial. That was with the contemplation that these first cases would go forward.
BRADY: I don't think the continuance is appropriate. There are no new issues for the defense. It allows them to test waters in other matters. They've filed this Hail Mary Motion on the eve of trial. I mean in this case it takes the heat off the defense.
Judge Fromholz gets out his calendar and the Kreutzer case jury trial, five days before it’s scheduled to begin, slips to August 6th.
======
EXTRA! EXTRA!
======
HUNDREDS OF DOCUMENTS HAVE DISAPPEARED FROM THE SUPERIOR COURT NETWORK“300 plus screens, pages and pages.” There it is in my April 3rd notes. So. . .
On April 3rd there were more than 300 screens of document names that link you to view the document, in the LA civil cases against the Catholic Church. Thursday a woman from the Court’s Public Information Office straightened me out on the “non-access to documents” problem.
“You just go forward starting from Document One, which won’t take that long,” she said.
I argued, No there are like 30,000 screens.
She went forward 10 screens at a time and there at screen 172 she was at a document filed June 4, 2007. I was humbled, apologized. I was sure there had been more screens than that.
THERE WERE MORE THAN 300 SCREENS THAN THAT
ON APRIL 3rd.
NOW THERE ARE ONLY 172 SCREENS LINKING TO DOCUMENTS
What happened to more than half the Clergy Case Documents?
In my notes April 3rd I remark that I’m on Screen 300 something. I estimated about 30 document names per screen, average. Okay 30,000 screens was a little off, but there are now less than half as many screens linking to documents as there were in April, and hundreds of documents have been filed in the 550 cases since last April.
There were more than 300 screens of documents in April. Now there are 172.
DO YOU UNDERSTAND THE WORDS THAT ARE COMING FROM MY LAPTOP???
Someone has removed more than half the documents from public access in the Clergy Cases.
Someone, maybe from both the church and plaintiffs sides, maybe even the judge, has removed more than half the documents that used to be available for the public to read in the ArcScanWeb network which maintains the Clergy Case files for LA Superior Court. (Private outsourced software contractor. . . .) (Who is paying attention to them?)
This comes directly after the “upgrade” by a private software firm on the Clergy Case JCCP documents section of the LA Superior Court network on May 31, last Thursday.
As of June 6th there are now only 172 screens. At least half the documents in the LA Clergy Cases 2007 have disappeared from the public access screens, both at the website and in Room 106 of Superior Court.
=====
The other hearings Wednesday covered a motion for protective order filed by a plaintiff (Denied) and a Motion to Compel a Non-Party to Comply with Deposition filed by Plaintiff (Granted). Next post will be a report on those two hearings. Both concern Hagenbach cases, now scheduled for jury trial July 9th.
More to come. . .
Wednesday, June 6, 2007
Hearing today on Mahony’s subpoena, access still denied to public records, church still fighting depositions.
*****
By City of Angels Lady
I had a weird day yesterday in and around Superior Court. Judge Fromholz granted a key Kreutzer case’s amended complaint, allowing her case against the church’s handling of sex criminal employee Paul Kreutzer to go into financial discovery as plaintiffs have shown they will “likely prevail,” as happens in California civil lawsuits.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) As you know City of Angels Blog carries no ads and takes no bribes. Just about the only place to find freedom of the press in America today is in blogs.
So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five to five hundred on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner. The money goes directly to me, Kay Ebeling, writer of this blog, and I report it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
I’m keeping alive an old American tradition, passing the hat. If I were a balladeer I’d be a street corner with my guitar, playing Beatles songs, then passing the hat for dollars and cents. So please put whatever cash you can on my Donate Button in the top left corner of this blog. If 350 people send me five dollars a month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
END COMMERCIAL BREAK**********
However, on Tuesday Church Attorneys did succeed in getting the Los Angeles Archdiocese Health and Welfare Corporation removed as defendant in Case BC308065. Even after the judge had issued his tentative ruling, Phillip Baker argued that Sister Frances Catherine, principal of Our Lady of Peace Elementary School, had nothing to do with corporate policy.
John Spano from the LA Times was behind me so I switched to 26 point bold type and put on my screen: "Trying to keep Sister Catherine the real culprit here out of the story” and I coughed and waved my hands around trying to subtly gesture, “read this, read this” but I don't think he saw it. Soon I was scrolled down past it.
Apparently Baker father and son won that round. Sister Catherine Frances, who traveled with Kreutzer, palled with him from back in the day, is being removed from the Kreutzer cases? I don't know for sure.
Apparently Church Attorneys argued that in the 1960s, around the time MS. Magazine appeared and feminism was rampant, the Nun who was principal of a Catholic school had no say in corporate policy.
Are there any nuns reading this?
----------
Public Access Still Denied in Clergy Case Files
Even the Times and people with paid accounts cannot read documents now
After the hearings I tried to go document diving and it was “access denied” all over the place. Note: A civil subpoena was served on Cardinal Mahony around May 22, and since May 31st, it’s been impossible to access any recent documents in the JCCP4286 case file, where all Clergy Cases are filed, separate from the rest of Los Angeles Superior Court Civil cases, with a separate sub-contract, (outsourced to the private sector) to a computer firm with a network called arc scan web.
When I realized the documents were still out of access I went back upstairs. There the LA Times reporter and a guy from Copley News (Yay there were two reporters there yesterday) were talking to a guy with a couple court employee badges dangling from his lapel.
I walked up and announced that access was still being denied and the John Spano said, Yes that's what we've been discussing here. The guy in dangling badges was the LA Superior Court PAO. So I said again, louder, all the details. They quote unquote upgraded last Thursday and since then there’s no way to access the documents.
Here is what I think is wrong with mainstream media today. These two guys in ties were holding a polite conversation with the Public Information officer. I went all Rosalind Russell and kept repeating, “Public access is denied to the documents, ever since Mahony got subpoenaed to testify.”
The PAO guy excused himself and acted like I was dirt under his shoes, but at this point in my life I don't care. I followed him down the hall repeating, Public access has been denied since Cardinal Mahony got a subpoena, don’t you think that's a strange coincidence? He scurried off with his hands over his ears, literally.
Later that day access was even worse than last week. Every document had been cut off. When you tried to access individual cases, which you could still do last week, you got this error message:
“Local cache access was denied.
Null.
Please report this problem to your website Administrator."
ACCESS GOT WORSE LATER
A few hours later, I’m back access still denied, so I try another approach
I’m inside the JCCP Network and the Java reader is OPENING.
Then a New message comes up:
“Local cache access was denied.
C:/Documents and settings/public/viewone/cache or c/ViewONE/cache originally defined as ‘’ Please report this problem to your Website Amar.”
I went to the Record Manager’s office and soon realized my synapses weren’t connecting right. Luckily Tuesdays at 11 AM I have Anger Management Class.
OVERHEARD AFTER COURT:
Plaintiff Liaison Tony DeMarco and Church Attorney Donald Woods sat outside after the hearings talking over what they were going to talk over with the judge in a few minutes.
I’m not tacky enough to write down all they said. I made a point of showing them, the tape player’s off, I’ve put down my pen. I’m just sitting here. Staring at Donald Woods. So as this practiced glad-hander -- he grins with leprechaun eyes, even taps you gently on the shoulder, as he weaves the words you absolutely don’t want to hear into the conversation -- went back and forth with Tony DeMarco, he’d look up at me now and then quizzically. Or just wanting someone to smile back.
Yesterday I wasn’t smiling. There was no place else for me to be so I just stared at Donald Woods as he argued. Church attorneys have not allowed “hierarchy” witnesses to answer key questions and plaintiffs have beaten against their walls for months trying to get fair depositions for fair discovery.
Woods: But we don’t want to pay for a referee to sit there all that time. . .
DeMarco: Then you shouldn't have been making so many objections.
(Okay, that one was too good to pass up. Remember I’m not a real journalist. I just have incredibly adaptive PTSD, I’m functionally insane. All my life I’ve adopted personae of other people, other professions. Right now I’d adopting the persona of a journalist to write this. In a year I'll be doing something else. That's my life as a priest rape survivor.)
----\
More Than a Thousand Hits in One Night
And I’m freaked thinking the Pope is reading this
It was a weird day for me yesterday as I woke up to find 1100 (eleven hundred) people had clicked on the blog post about Crimen Solicitatis overnight, and I felt weird like the Vatican was watching me. Then I realized, Hey, when the pope was Cardinal Ratzinger, he essentially leaked the document, Crimen Solicitatis by footnoting it in that 2001 document. So maybe the current pope can see the “Jesus” in people power and open public information as experienced in America. I hope he is reading this. But it made me uncomfortable.
=======
SAMPLING OF TRANSCRIPTION
From Hearing on Kreutzer Cases June 5
CHURCH ATTORNEY PHILLIP BAKER: The crux of the order is the bottom of Page 4 the paragraph saying Sister Catherine is agent. They've let no evidence that she’s a managing agent.
Question is not if she had authority at school but can she control corporate policy. Managing agent is to include only corporate employees with corporate decision making who affect policy.
Here is where I typed in: “Trying to keep Sister Catherine the real culprit here out of the story” trying to get the Times to read my screen.
CHURCH ATTORNEY PHIL BAKER CONTINUED: She was principal at Our Lady of Peace but did she have any role in the Archdiocese? She had a role in the abuse reports but she didn't have anything to do with corporate policy.
I think the court ought to just look I respectfully submit.
We're involved in settlement discussions. I didn't ask them to wait ‘til the eve of trial to file a motion.
Baker picks up his papers and frowns.
PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY STEVE BRADY: It’s the standard for the acts whether they constitute malice. Not Sister Catherine as managing agent but evidence of corporate policy.
(Baker is swaggering and shaking his head, as Brady talks. He holds his hand up like a kid who can’t wait as Brady is talking.)
BRADY: All we need to show is we meet the minimum requirements necessary to go to jury.
(Brady turns pointedly to defendant attorneys.)
BRADY: Mr. Woods begged plaintiff not to file this motion February 18th and we've had numerous conversations up to time this motion was filed. He said it would affect the status of “certain entities ie the insurance companies in this case.”
“We had to file this order to get this heard before we started trial. The timing was made and set up by the defense.”
JUDGE” You only have to show a preponderance of evidence that Sister Frances Catherine was
BRADY: Just that she committed the acts. This is not a summary judgment.
JUDGE: I do have one question. The second amended complaint names two defendants
PLAINTIFFS: We do that on the record now. The Second amended complaint filed before dismissal of the Education and Welfare Corporation
BAKER: (TRIUMPHANTLY!) There’s only one defendant now.
JUDGE: I need to talk to counsel briefly.
(They all go off into court’s back room and when they come out it appears to me that the plaintiffs are smiling and Baker et all are getting red in the face. The elder Baker holds the gate open and leads his son who trounces out of the room.
EMAIL FROM DANIEL SHEA
Published with his permission
Fun part of writing this blog is emails I get from people reaction to it. This came in from Daniel Shea attorney in Houston who took the Fort Worth cases to Washington in 2004, (and while pursuing cases in Massachusetts, unearthed the Crimen Solicitatis document).
“Actually, crimen was used as summary judgment evidence in the Fort Worth diocese case. The diocese made the mistake of trying to marginalize crimen using an affidavit of John Beal, a canon lawyer at Catholic University. John and I were theology classmates at Louvain in the 70s! Tendering his affidavit opened the door for me to take his deposition after a big struggle. All eight hours are on both text and video and in my opinion reasonably authenticate the document. The Beal deposition was then used extensively in the plainiff's opposition to the diocese's motion to summarily dismiss the case. That motion was denied without further comment by the court and the case was settled for almost 4 million for the 2 plaintiffs.
When reading crimen, don’t miss Formula B, the "Formula of Abjuration." In order to obtain the bishops absolution, the priest has to state that "no one can be saved unless he believes what the holy Roman catholic church teaches, preaches, confesses and practices." That little nugget, according to Ratzinger's letter, is part of a document that had been in full force and effect from 1962 until at least Ratzinger's May 18, 2001 letter. What does that tell you about the extent to which the conservatives never lost their grip on the church -- the best efforts of John 23rd notwithstanding.
Daniel Shea, Attorney
======
Later on the way home I’m thinking about this weird day.
That's when it dawned on me. . .
The reason I lived through all those overdoses in the 1980s. Yesterday after the hearing, there was no place else for me to be at that moment other than sitting on the bench across from Church Attorney Donald Woods and Plaintiff Liaison Tony DeMarco and just being there. He had to see me whether he wanted to or not.
Excuse the typos etcetera, I'm running out the door.
Hearing today on Mahony’s subpoena.
By City of Angels Lady
I had a weird day yesterday in and around Superior Court. Judge Fromholz granted a key Kreutzer case’s amended complaint, allowing her case against the church’s handling of sex criminal employee Paul Kreutzer to go into financial discovery as plaintiffs have shown they will “likely prevail,” as happens in California civil lawsuits.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) As you know City of Angels Blog carries no ads and takes no bribes. Just about the only place to find freedom of the press in America today is in blogs.
So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five to five hundred on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner. The money goes directly to me, Kay Ebeling, writer of this blog, and I report it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
I’m keeping alive an old American tradition, passing the hat. If I were a balladeer I’d be a street corner with my guitar, playing Beatles songs, then passing the hat for dollars and cents. So please put whatever cash you can on my Donate Button in the top left corner of this blog. If 350 people send me five dollars a month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
END COMMERCIAL BREAK**********
However, on Tuesday Church Attorneys did succeed in getting the Los Angeles Archdiocese Health and Welfare Corporation removed as defendant in Case BC308065. Even after the judge had issued his tentative ruling, Phillip Baker argued that Sister Frances Catherine, principal of Our Lady of Peace Elementary School, had nothing to do with corporate policy.
John Spano from the LA Times was behind me so I switched to 26 point bold type and put on my screen: "Trying to keep Sister Catherine the real culprit here out of the story” and I coughed and waved my hands around trying to subtly gesture, “read this, read this” but I don't think he saw it. Soon I was scrolled down past it.
Apparently Baker father and son won that round. Sister Catherine Frances, who traveled with Kreutzer, palled with him from back in the day, is being removed from the Kreutzer cases? I don't know for sure.
Apparently Church Attorneys argued that in the 1960s, around the time MS. Magazine appeared and feminism was rampant, the Nun who was principal of a Catholic school had no say in corporate policy.
Are there any nuns reading this?
----------
Public Access Still Denied in Clergy Case Files
Even the Times and people with paid accounts cannot read documents now
After the hearings I tried to go document diving and it was “access denied” all over the place. Note: A civil subpoena was served on Cardinal Mahony around May 22, and since May 31st, it’s been impossible to access any recent documents in the JCCP4286 case file, where all Clergy Cases are filed, separate from the rest of Los Angeles Superior Court Civil cases, with a separate sub-contract, (outsourced to the private sector) to a computer firm with a network called arc scan web.
When I realized the documents were still out of access I went back upstairs. There the LA Times reporter and a guy from Copley News (Yay there were two reporters there yesterday) were talking to a guy with a couple court employee badges dangling from his lapel.
I walked up and announced that access was still being denied and the John Spano said, Yes that's what we've been discussing here. The guy in dangling badges was the LA Superior Court PAO. So I said again, louder, all the details. They quote unquote upgraded last Thursday and since then there’s no way to access the documents.
Here is what I think is wrong with mainstream media today. These two guys in ties were holding a polite conversation with the Public Information officer. I went all Rosalind Russell and kept repeating, “Public access is denied to the documents, ever since Mahony got subpoenaed to testify.”
The PAO guy excused himself and acted like I was dirt under his shoes, but at this point in my life I don't care. I followed him down the hall repeating, Public access has been denied since Cardinal Mahony got a subpoena, don’t you think that's a strange coincidence? He scurried off with his hands over his ears, literally.
Later that day access was even worse than last week. Every document had been cut off. When you tried to access individual cases, which you could still do last week, you got this error message:
“Local cache access was denied.
Null.
Please report this problem to your website Administrator."
ACCESS GOT WORSE LATER
A few hours later, I’m back access still denied, so I try another approach
I’m inside the JCCP Network and the Java reader is OPENING.
Then a New message comes up:
“Local cache access was denied.
C:/Documents and settings/public/viewone/cache or c/ViewONE/cache originally defined as ‘
I went to the Record Manager’s office and soon realized my synapses weren’t connecting right. Luckily Tuesdays at 11 AM I have Anger Management Class.
OVERHEARD AFTER COURT:
Plaintiff Liaison Tony DeMarco and Church Attorney Donald Woods sat outside after the hearings talking over what they were going to talk over with the judge in a few minutes.
I’m not tacky enough to write down all they said. I made a point of showing them, the tape player’s off, I’ve put down my pen. I’m just sitting here. Staring at Donald Woods. So as this practiced glad-hander -- he grins with leprechaun eyes, even taps you gently on the shoulder, as he weaves the words you absolutely don’t want to hear into the conversation -- went back and forth with Tony DeMarco, he’d look up at me now and then quizzically. Or just wanting someone to smile back.
Yesterday I wasn’t smiling. There was no place else for me to be so I just stared at Donald Woods as he argued. Church attorneys have not allowed “hierarchy” witnesses to answer key questions and plaintiffs have beaten against their walls for months trying to get fair depositions for fair discovery.
Woods: But we don’t want to pay for a referee to sit there all that time. . .
DeMarco: Then you shouldn't have been making so many objections.
(Okay, that one was too good to pass up. Remember I’m not a real journalist. I just have incredibly adaptive PTSD, I’m functionally insane. All my life I’ve adopted personae of other people, other professions. Right now I’d adopting the persona of a journalist to write this. In a year I'll be doing something else. That's my life as a priest rape survivor.)
----\
More Than a Thousand Hits in One Night
And I’m freaked thinking the Pope is reading this
It was a weird day for me yesterday as I woke up to find 1100 (eleven hundred) people had clicked on the blog post about Crimen Solicitatis overnight, and I felt weird like the Vatican was watching me. Then I realized, Hey, when the pope was Cardinal Ratzinger, he essentially leaked the document, Crimen Solicitatis by footnoting it in that 2001 document. So maybe the current pope can see the “Jesus” in people power and open public information as experienced in America. I hope he is reading this. But it made me uncomfortable.
=======
SAMPLING OF TRANSCRIPTION
From Hearing on Kreutzer Cases June 5
CHURCH ATTORNEY PHILLIP BAKER: The crux of the order is the bottom of Page 4 the paragraph saying Sister Catherine is agent. They've let no evidence that she’s a managing agent.
Question is not if she had authority at school but can she control corporate policy. Managing agent is to include only corporate employees with corporate decision making who affect policy.
Here is where I typed in: “Trying to keep Sister Catherine the real culprit here out of the story” trying to get the Times to read my screen.
CHURCH ATTORNEY PHIL BAKER CONTINUED: She was principal at Our Lady of Peace but did she have any role in the Archdiocese? She had a role in the abuse reports but she didn't have anything to do with corporate policy.
I think the court ought to just look I respectfully submit.
We're involved in settlement discussions. I didn't ask them to wait ‘til the eve of trial to file a motion.
Baker picks up his papers and frowns.
PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY STEVE BRADY: It’s the standard for the acts whether they constitute malice. Not Sister Catherine as managing agent but evidence of corporate policy.
(Baker is swaggering and shaking his head, as Brady talks. He holds his hand up like a kid who can’t wait as Brady is talking.)
BRADY: All we need to show is we meet the minimum requirements necessary to go to jury.
(Brady turns pointedly to defendant attorneys.)
BRADY: Mr. Woods begged plaintiff not to file this motion February 18th and we've had numerous conversations up to time this motion was filed. He said it would affect the status of “certain entities ie the insurance companies in this case.”
“We had to file this order to get this heard before we started trial. The timing was made and set up by the defense.”
JUDGE” You only have to show a preponderance of evidence that Sister Frances Catherine was
BRADY: Just that she committed the acts. This is not a summary judgment.
JUDGE: I do have one question. The second amended complaint names two defendants
PLAINTIFFS: We do that on the record now. The Second amended complaint filed before dismissal of the Education and Welfare Corporation
BAKER: (TRIUMPHANTLY!) There’s only one defendant now.
JUDGE: I need to talk to counsel briefly.
(They all go off into court’s back room and when they come out it appears to me that the plaintiffs are smiling and Baker et all are getting red in the face. The elder Baker holds the gate open and leads his son who trounces out of the room.
EMAIL FROM DANIEL SHEA
Published with his permission
Fun part of writing this blog is emails I get from people reaction to it. This came in from Daniel Shea attorney in Houston who took the Fort Worth cases to Washington in 2004, (and while pursuing cases in Massachusetts, unearthed the Crimen Solicitatis document).
“Actually, crimen was used as summary judgment evidence in the Fort Worth diocese case. The diocese made the mistake of trying to marginalize crimen using an affidavit of John Beal, a canon lawyer at Catholic University. John and I were theology classmates at Louvain in the 70s! Tendering his affidavit opened the door for me to take his deposition after a big struggle. All eight hours are on both text and video and in my opinion reasonably authenticate the document. The Beal deposition was then used extensively in the plainiff's opposition to the diocese's motion to summarily dismiss the case. That motion was denied without further comment by the court and the case was settled for almost 4 million for the 2 plaintiffs.
When reading crimen, don’t miss Formula B, the "Formula of Abjuration." In order to obtain the bishops absolution, the priest has to state that "no one can be saved unless he believes what the holy Roman catholic church teaches, preaches, confesses and practices." That little nugget, according to Ratzinger's letter, is part of a document that had been in full force and effect from 1962 until at least Ratzinger's May 18, 2001 letter. What does that tell you about the extent to which the conservatives never lost their grip on the church -- the best efforts of John 23rd notwithstanding.
Daniel Shea, Attorney
======
Later on the way home I’m thinking about this weird day.
That's when it dawned on me. . .
The reason I lived through all those overdoses in the 1980s. Yesterday after the hearing, there was no place else for me to be at that moment other than sitting on the bench across from Church Attorney Donald Woods and Plaintiff Liaison Tony DeMarco and just being there. He had to see me whether he wanted to or not.
Excuse the typos etcetera, I'm running out the door.
Hearing today on Mahony’s subpoena.
Monday, June 4, 2007
1962 Holy Office doctrine shows Church Policy was aiding and abetting, coverup, and secrecy, from the Vatican to Bishops, re sex crimes among priests
*****
By City of Angels lady
(This is a double length post:) Since so many sex crimes that will come up in jury trials the next months in civil cases against the LA Archdiocese took place from 1962 to 2001, plaintiff attorneys may want to enter the 1962 document Crimen Sollicitationis, the hierarchical blueprint written in Latin from the Pope to all bishops.
Directly underneath the title are instructions to hide the document in secret places and tell no one of its contents.
American Catholic bishops handled Sex Crimes in the American Catholic Church for the next decades as laid out in the 1962 Crimen Solicitationes document. The document makes it clear that the Catholics' mishandling of sex crimes was official policy and the result in Southern California was a network of pedophiles that operated free and unfettered within church confines. These 1962 “instructions” to bishops are at the heart of the Catholic Church’s nationwide mishandling of sex crimes among its priests.
California Was the Nation's Rural Grounds
So it bred generations of pedophiles within the church
In the 1960s and 1970s Southern California was like the nation’s rural district. As a result, the entire archdiocese, or the entire Southern California region was flooded with pedophiles. Indeed active predators worked as recruiters at Seminaries, so the pedophilia developed into a second generation network.
A quick read of documents regarding cases coming to trial in the next months shows that throughout Southern California, pedophilia took place out in the open in rectories and seminary dormitories. There are likely thousands of damaged people walking around California and the West. With the number of predator priests already identified in and around Los Angeles, it’s a good guess there are thousands of victims of predator priests who have never come forward.
In California priests raped children in the church behind the altars, in pre-Mass altar boy ceremonies, openly in the rectories -- and secrecy and covering up the crimes became standard operating procedure, as outlined in these instructions to the bishops Crimen Solicitationes.
Previous Attempts to Introduce Crimen Solicitationes as Evidence have been Shot Down.
No city is better than LA for introduction of Crimen Solicitationis as Evidence of Crimes Covered Up for the Sake of the Church
In Boston and Texas, all the way to the Supreme Court in Washington DC plaintiffs have tried to introduce Crimen Sollicitationis as evidence that the general practice of the Catholic Church was aiding and abetting in handling sex crimes committed by priests. It also came up in Louisville, Kentucky cases in 2003.
“A move in 2004 to get the document admitted in Massachusetts failed recently when a Springfield judge ruled the document was irrelevant to a civil lawsuit alleging clergy sexual abuse,” reported Kathleen A. Shaw in the Telegram & Gazette August 24, 2004.
In the case that went from Texas to Washington DC Crimen was ruled out as evidence as the plaintiffs were not Catholic as children when the crimes took place.
But with the rampant out of control pedophilia that festered in Southern California from the 1960s to the 1990s, in no other city could the document Crimen Sollicitatis be more relevant as evidence in the civil trials.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) As you know City of Angels Blog carries no ads and takes no bribes. Just about the only place to find freedom of the press in America today is in blogs.
So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five to five hundred on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner. The money goes directly to me, Kay Ebeling, writer of this blog, and I report it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
I’m keeping alive an old American tradition, passing the hat. If I were a balladeer I’d be a street corner with my guitar, playing Beatles songs, then passing the hat for dollars and cents. So please put whatever cash you can on my Donate Button in the top left corner of this blog. If 350 people send me five dollars a month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
END COMMERCIAL BREAK**********
BACK TO CRIMEN SOLICITATIONIS
When I’m cycling manic narcissist I think the pope and cardinals came up with Crimen Solicitationis in 1962 after the way the Chicago Archdiocese handled the case of me and my sister in 1955.
Don’t let anyone convince you that Crimen Solicitationis applies only to “Sollicitation” in the confessional although Catholic defenders argued that in 2004. The title is, I think, designed to give the impression the document is only about the Confessional, in just one more way to obfuscate the truth from the non-hierarchical Catholic.
The first page of Crimen Sollicitationis, before the text begins and directly underneath the title it reads “On the manner of proceeding in cases of the crime of solicitation,
“This text is to be diligently stored in the secret archives of the Curia as strictly confidential. Nor is it to be published nor added to with any commentaries.
Right in the 1962 document the church admits the permanent damage sex abuse by a priest can do in its own words. Paragraph 15 states in Latin that anyone who knows of such crimes and does not report them should be excommunicated --
"lest [the offense] remain occult and unpublished and always with inestimable detriment to souls." (Source National Catholic Reporter article August 7, 2003).
---------
A Boston Lawyer Discovers the 1962 Document
Still Rocking the Vatican in 2007
“Crimen Solicitationis” may have forever been a secret except it was referenced in a footnote to a May 18, 2002, in a letter from then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, (now Pope Benedict) head of the Vatican's doctrinal congregation. He was apparently giving direction to bishops of the world on new policy for handling sex abuse cases.
Boston Lawyer Daniel J. Shea unearthed the document and sent a copy to a U.S. Attorney in 2004. Immediately Church Attorneys argued that the document was irrelevant as most bishops didn't even know it existed.
Right. An entreaty from the Vatican in 1962 written in Latin with strictest instructions to store it in a secret place and tell no one about it, and none of the bishops knew it existed….
These are the same Church Attorneys who will try to argue Crimen is only about crimes in the Confessional.
Survivor priest Robert Hoatson’s original lawsuit in New York mentions the Crimen document : “In 1961, the Vatican issued a document entitled "Crimen Solicitationes" which ordered bishops to keep secreted documents and information relating to the sexual abuse of minors. The Church has had a long-standing regulation that crimes are not to be reported or adjudicated so as not to cause the church public scandal.”
Continued from Hoatson’s original complaint: “My attempts to report my own abuse and abuse of children, teenagers, and vulnerable adults were thwarted by a culture of secrecy, cover-up, and lying.”
Since publication in 2001 the document has been copied and posted on websites. In October 2006 the BBC program, "Sex Crimes and the Vatican," aired in England and this May it was finally broadcast in Italy on a show called “The Year Zero.” However in the weeks prior to the official Italian broadcast, Google video ran the show with Italian subtitles. So the truth about Crimen Solicitationis has now even reached residents of Rome.
NOTE: The Google Video of the BBC program with Italian subtitles in linked on the left.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) As you know City of Angels Blog carries no ads and takes no bribes. Just about the only place to find freedom of the press in America today is in blogs. So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five to five hundred on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner. The money goes directly to me, Kay Ebeling, writer of this blog, and I report it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
I’m keeping alive an old American tradition, passing the hat. If I were a balladeer I’d be a street corner with my guitar, playing Beatles songs, then passing the hat for dollars and cents. So please put whatever cash you can on my Donate Button in the top left corner of this blog. If 350 people send me five dollars a month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
Every little bit helps.
Kay Ebeling
END COMMERCIAL BREAK**********
======
More on Crimen Sollicitationis:
“Exhibit A is a hitherto secret document called Crimen Sollicationis - Latin for "the crime of solicitation" - issued in 1962 by the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF), an office attached to the Vatican. Described as a "blueprint for deception and concealment" by lawyers investigating the worldwide sex-abuse scandals, Crimen Sollicationis contains strict instructions for dealing with what the Vatican calls the "worst crimes" - such as allegations of paedophilia and bestiality. Rather than report these offences to the civil authorities, the CDF instructs bishops to investigate them "in the most secretive way" or face the "penalty of excommunication".
From
'Everywhere I Turned, I Ran into Sexual Abuse'
The Guardian
May 4, 2006
http://www.guardian.co.uk/religion/Story/0,,1766941,00.html
---------
Bishops still referred to Crimen Solicitationis in 2002
And thanks to Boston area reporter we know that about it
Some more reporting from Kathy Shaw this in 2003 from Worchester, Massachusetts: (The same Kathy Shaw who now produces Abuse Tracker as a daily blog for Bishop Accountability dot org.)
"The newsletters of the Canon Law Society show that officers met in Rome in February 2002, a time when the church-wide sexual abuse scandal broke open in Boston with new revelations about the extent of clergy sexual abuse within the Boston Archdiocese.
"In this meeting with representatives of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the newsletter said, "Our discussion at the Congregation focused on identification of certain aspects of procedures for clergy sexual misconduct, particularly the 1962 instruction "Crimen Sollicitationes" and the more recent instruction "Sacramentorum Sanctitatis Tutela."
Sacramentorum Sactitatis Tutela "went on the Vatican Web site in 2002, and the English translation clearly shows that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, who heads the Congregation for the Doctine of the Faith, indicated that the 1962 directive was in effect "until now." Mr. Shea did not know the 1962 document existed until he saw it footnoted in the Ratzinger document."
==========
QUOTES FROM THE DOCUMENT ITSELF
Translated and available all over the internet today
==========
Here are direct quotes from a PDF File of Crimen Solicitationis translated from Latin into English. Since the Boston public uncovering of this document in 2001 it’s been copied and translated all over the web.
PDFs are available at bishop accountability dot org of course.
Centered
From the Supreme and Holy Congregation of the Holy Office
Centered
For all Patriarchs, Archbishops, Bishops, and Other Diocesan Ordinaries “Even of the Oriental Rite”
Centered Underlined:
Instruction:
Centered
On the Manner of Proceeding In Cases of Solicitation
Centered
The Vatican Press 1962
Instruction
Then the text begins:
‘On the manner of proceeding in cases of the crime of solicitation,
“This text is to be diligently stored in the secret archives of the Curia as strictly confidential. Nor is it to be published nor added to with any commentaries.
“the crime of solicitation takes place when a priest tempts a penitent.
It then specifies in several lines whether in the confessional or any number of other places
“The object of this temptation is to solicit or provoke the penitent toward impure or obscene matters.”
Whether by words, nods, touches, a three line list of ways --
Paragraph 2. The right or duty of addressing this unspeakable crime --
First and foremost the responsibility of the “ordinaries of the place”
“not to mention through proper law but also through a special delegation of the Apostolic See;
. . . “that they as soon as possible take care to introduce, discuss, and terminate these cases with their proper tribunal. . .
Hmm doesn't seem like the bishops stuck to that part. . .
“HOWEVER, because of particular and serious reasons these cases can be directly deferred to the Holy Congregation of the Holy Office or be so ordered.
Oh there it is in Paragraph 2, if it’s a really horrible crime, you can bypass the proper law and report it and deal with it at the level of the Holy Office. . . .
There are then several paragraphs explaining the hierarchy. . . to whom these crimes can be -- buck passed up and ways to avoid public knowledge of the crimes.
By paragraph 6 we're still talking about the “judges”
“6. Although as a rule, a single judge, by reason of its secrecy is prescribed for cases of this type.. .
In the middle of Paragraph 9:
“Because of the special nature of these procedures, however, it is necessary for the Ordinary to dispense from the presence of the notary.”
Paragraph 11:
“11. Because however, what is treated in these cases has to have a greater degree of care and observance so that those same matters be pursued in a most secretive way. And after they have been defined and given over to execution, they are to be restrained by a perpetual silence.”
Anyone who knows about these crimes is to “observe the strictest ++7++ secret, which is commonly regarded as a secret of the Holy Office."
“. . . Under the penalty of Excommunication."
Several more paragraphs on why and how these crimes need to be “executed” and maintained in secret.
Paragraph 15.
“15. Since the crime of solicitation takes place in rather rare decisions, lest it remain occult and unpublished and always with inestimable detriment of souls. . .
Yes the Catholic Church admitted even then the permanent damage from this crime.
“19. The duty of denunciation is a personal one and is to be fulfilled regularly by the person himself who has been solicited.
Report it to the Holy Office. Don’t be anonymous.
RE PENALTIES conferred on priests
By this Internal Judiciary
The document goes on to Paragraph 62:
“penalties decreed against priests convicted of the crime of solicitation, with an equal regard for the mind of CANON 2218. . . for estimating the gravity of the crime, -- and their condition, as for example they are minors in age or especially consecrated. . .
64. c: Those who are in danger of falling back into their former ways and therefore becoming greater recidivists should be submitted to particular vigilance.
65. As often as it seems “necessary for the amendment of the delinquent, for the removal of the near occasion of soliciting in the future, or for the prevention of scandal or for the reparation for it, there should be added a prescription for the prohibition of remaining in a certain place.”
This is the part that Boston’s Daniel Shea said lead to the priests being sent places like The Servants of the Paracletes in New Mexico, what Shea described as “vacations"
The more I learn about this whole subject the more it seems it will take a federal RICO (Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act) investigation to bring the whole story out into the open and finally get justice.
=========
More to Come. . .
By City of Angels lady
(This is a double length post:) Since so many sex crimes that will come up in jury trials the next months in civil cases against the LA Archdiocese took place from 1962 to 2001, plaintiff attorneys may want to enter the 1962 document Crimen Sollicitationis, the hierarchical blueprint written in Latin from the Pope to all bishops.
Directly underneath the title are instructions to hide the document in secret places and tell no one of its contents.
American Catholic bishops handled Sex Crimes in the American Catholic Church for the next decades as laid out in the 1962 Crimen Solicitationes document. The document makes it clear that the Catholics' mishandling of sex crimes was official policy and the result in Southern California was a network of pedophiles that operated free and unfettered within church confines. These 1962 “instructions” to bishops are at the heart of the Catholic Church’s nationwide mishandling of sex crimes among its priests.
California Was the Nation's Rural Grounds
So it bred generations of pedophiles within the church
In the 1960s and 1970s Southern California was like the nation’s rural district. As a result, the entire archdiocese, or the entire Southern California region was flooded with pedophiles. Indeed active predators worked as recruiters at Seminaries, so the pedophilia developed into a second generation network.
A quick read of documents regarding cases coming to trial in the next months shows that throughout Southern California, pedophilia took place out in the open in rectories and seminary dormitories. There are likely thousands of damaged people walking around California and the West. With the number of predator priests already identified in and around Los Angeles, it’s a good guess there are thousands of victims of predator priests who have never come forward.
In California priests raped children in the church behind the altars, in pre-Mass altar boy ceremonies, openly in the rectories -- and secrecy and covering up the crimes became standard operating procedure, as outlined in these instructions to the bishops Crimen Solicitationes.
Previous Attempts to Introduce Crimen Solicitationes as Evidence have been Shot Down.
No city is better than LA for introduction of Crimen Solicitationis as Evidence of Crimes Covered Up for the Sake of the Church
In Boston and Texas, all the way to the Supreme Court in Washington DC plaintiffs have tried to introduce Crimen Sollicitationis as evidence that the general practice of the Catholic Church was aiding and abetting in handling sex crimes committed by priests. It also came up in Louisville, Kentucky cases in 2003.
“A move in 2004 to get the document admitted in Massachusetts failed recently when a Springfield judge ruled the document was irrelevant to a civil lawsuit alleging clergy sexual abuse,” reported Kathleen A. Shaw in the Telegram & Gazette August 24, 2004.
In the case that went from Texas to Washington DC Crimen was ruled out as evidence as the plaintiffs were not Catholic as children when the crimes took place.
But with the rampant out of control pedophilia that festered in Southern California from the 1960s to the 1990s, in no other city could the document Crimen Sollicitatis be more relevant as evidence in the civil trials.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) As you know City of Angels Blog carries no ads and takes no bribes. Just about the only place to find freedom of the press in America today is in blogs.
So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five to five hundred on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner. The money goes directly to me, Kay Ebeling, writer of this blog, and I report it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
I’m keeping alive an old American tradition, passing the hat. If I were a balladeer I’d be a street corner with my guitar, playing Beatles songs, then passing the hat for dollars and cents. So please put whatever cash you can on my Donate Button in the top left corner of this blog. If 350 people send me five dollars a month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
END COMMERCIAL BREAK**********
BACK TO CRIMEN SOLICITATIONIS
When I’m cycling manic narcissist I think the pope and cardinals came up with Crimen Solicitationis in 1962 after the way the Chicago Archdiocese handled the case of me and my sister in 1955.
Don’t let anyone convince you that Crimen Solicitationis applies only to “Sollicitation” in the confessional although Catholic defenders argued that in 2004. The title is, I think, designed to give the impression the document is only about the Confessional, in just one more way to obfuscate the truth from the non-hierarchical Catholic.
The first page of Crimen Sollicitationis, before the text begins and directly underneath the title it reads “On the manner of proceeding in cases of the crime of solicitation,
“This text is to be diligently stored in the secret archives of the Curia as strictly confidential. Nor is it to be published nor added to with any commentaries.
Right in the 1962 document the church admits the permanent damage sex abuse by a priest can do in its own words. Paragraph 15 states in Latin that anyone who knows of such crimes and does not report them should be excommunicated --
"lest [the offense] remain occult and unpublished and always with inestimable detriment to souls." (Source National Catholic Reporter article August 7, 2003).
---------
A Boston Lawyer Discovers the 1962 Document
Still Rocking the Vatican in 2007
“Crimen Solicitationis” may have forever been a secret except it was referenced in a footnote to a May 18, 2002, in a letter from then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, (now Pope Benedict) head of the Vatican's doctrinal congregation. He was apparently giving direction to bishops of the world on new policy for handling sex abuse cases.
Boston Lawyer Daniel J. Shea unearthed the document and sent a copy to a U.S. Attorney in 2004. Immediately Church Attorneys argued that the document was irrelevant as most bishops didn't even know it existed.
Right. An entreaty from the Vatican in 1962 written in Latin with strictest instructions to store it in a secret place and tell no one about it, and none of the bishops knew it existed….
These are the same Church Attorneys who will try to argue Crimen is only about crimes in the Confessional.
Survivor priest Robert Hoatson’s original lawsuit in New York mentions the Crimen document : “In 1961, the Vatican issued a document entitled "Crimen Solicitationes" which ordered bishops to keep secreted documents and information relating to the sexual abuse of minors. The Church has had a long-standing regulation that crimes are not to be reported or adjudicated so as not to cause the church public scandal.”
Continued from Hoatson’s original complaint: “My attempts to report my own abuse and abuse of children, teenagers, and vulnerable adults were thwarted by a culture of secrecy, cover-up, and lying.”
Since publication in 2001 the document has been copied and posted on websites. In October 2006 the BBC program, "Sex Crimes and the Vatican," aired in England and this May it was finally broadcast in Italy on a show called “The Year Zero.” However in the weeks prior to the official Italian broadcast, Google video ran the show with Italian subtitles. So the truth about Crimen Solicitationis has now even reached residents of Rome.
NOTE: The Google Video of the BBC program with Italian subtitles in linked on the left.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) As you know City of Angels Blog carries no ads and takes no bribes. Just about the only place to find freedom of the press in America today is in blogs. So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five to five hundred on the Pay-Pal Account. Just click the “Make Donation” button in the top left corner. The money goes directly to me, Kay Ebeling, writer of this blog, and I report it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
I’m keeping alive an old American tradition, passing the hat. If I were a balladeer I’d be a street corner with my guitar, playing Beatles songs, then passing the hat for dollars and cents. So please put whatever cash you can on my Donate Button in the top left corner of this blog. If 350 people send me five dollars a month I can cover my rent and bills and work full time on this reporting.
Every little bit helps.
Kay Ebeling
END COMMERCIAL BREAK**********
======
More on Crimen Sollicitationis:
“Exhibit A is a hitherto secret document called Crimen Sollicationis - Latin for "the crime of solicitation" - issued in 1962 by the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF), an office attached to the Vatican. Described as a "blueprint for deception and concealment" by lawyers investigating the worldwide sex-abuse scandals, Crimen Sollicationis contains strict instructions for dealing with what the Vatican calls the "worst crimes" - such as allegations of paedophilia and bestiality. Rather than report these offences to the civil authorities, the CDF instructs bishops to investigate them "in the most secretive way" or face the "penalty of excommunication".
From
'Everywhere I Turned, I Ran into Sexual Abuse'
The Guardian
May 4, 2006
http://www.guardian.co.uk/religion/Story/0,,1766941,00.html
---------
Bishops still referred to Crimen Solicitationis in 2002
And thanks to Boston area reporter we know that about it
Some more reporting from Kathy Shaw this in 2003 from Worchester, Massachusetts: (The same Kathy Shaw who now produces Abuse Tracker as a daily blog for Bishop Accountability dot org.)
"The newsletters of the Canon Law Society show that officers met in Rome in February 2002, a time when the church-wide sexual abuse scandal broke open in Boston with new revelations about the extent of clergy sexual abuse within the Boston Archdiocese.
"In this meeting with representatives of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the newsletter said, "Our discussion at the Congregation focused on identification of certain aspects of procedures for clergy sexual misconduct, particularly the 1962 instruction "Crimen Sollicitationes" and the more recent instruction "Sacramentorum Sanctitatis Tutela."
Sacramentorum Sactitatis Tutela "went on the Vatican Web site in 2002, and the English translation clearly shows that Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, who heads the Congregation for the Doctine of the Faith, indicated that the 1962 directive was in effect "until now." Mr. Shea did not know the 1962 document existed until he saw it footnoted in the Ratzinger document."
==========
QUOTES FROM THE DOCUMENT ITSELF
Translated and available all over the internet today
==========
Here are direct quotes from a PDF File of Crimen Solicitationis translated from Latin into English. Since the Boston public uncovering of this document in 2001 it’s been copied and translated all over the web.
PDFs are available at bishop accountability dot org of course.
Centered
From the Supreme and Holy Congregation of the Holy Office
Centered
For all Patriarchs, Archbishops, Bishops, and Other Diocesan Ordinaries “Even of the Oriental Rite”
Centered Underlined:
Instruction:
Centered
On the Manner of Proceeding In Cases of Solicitation
Centered
The Vatican Press 1962
Instruction
Then the text begins:
‘On the manner of proceeding in cases of the crime of solicitation,
“This text is to be diligently stored in the secret archives of the Curia as strictly confidential. Nor is it to be published nor added to with any commentaries.
“the crime of solicitation takes place when a priest tempts a penitent.
It then specifies in several lines whether in the confessional or any number of other places
“The object of this temptation is to solicit or provoke the penitent toward impure or obscene matters.”
Whether by words, nods, touches, a three line list of ways --
Paragraph 2. The right or duty of addressing this unspeakable crime --
First and foremost the responsibility of the “ordinaries of the place”
“not to mention through proper law but also through a special delegation of the Apostolic See;
. . . “that they as soon as possible take care to introduce, discuss, and terminate these cases with their proper tribunal. . .
Hmm doesn't seem like the bishops stuck to that part. . .
“HOWEVER, because of particular and serious reasons these cases can be directly deferred to the Holy Congregation of the Holy Office or be so ordered.
Oh there it is in Paragraph 2, if it’s a really horrible crime, you can bypass the proper law and report it and deal with it at the level of the Holy Office. . . .
There are then several paragraphs explaining the hierarchy. . . to whom these crimes can be -- buck passed up and ways to avoid public knowledge of the crimes.
By paragraph 6 we're still talking about the “judges”
“6. Although as a rule, a single judge, by reason of its secrecy is prescribed for cases of this type.. .
In the middle of Paragraph 9:
“Because of the special nature of these procedures, however, it is necessary for the Ordinary to dispense from the presence of the notary.”
Paragraph 11:
“11. Because however, what is treated in these cases has to have a greater degree of care and observance so that those same matters be pursued in a most secretive way. And after they have been defined and given over to execution, they are to be restrained by a perpetual silence.”
Anyone who knows about these crimes is to “observe the strictest ++7++ secret, which is commonly regarded as a secret of the Holy Office."
“. . . Under the penalty of Excommunication."
Several more paragraphs on why and how these crimes need to be “executed” and maintained in secret.
Paragraph 15.
“15. Since the crime of solicitation takes place in rather rare decisions, lest it remain occult and unpublished and always with inestimable detriment of souls. . .
Yes the Catholic Church admitted even then the permanent damage from this crime.
“19. The duty of denunciation is a personal one and is to be fulfilled regularly by the person himself who has been solicited.
Report it to the Holy Office. Don’t be anonymous.
RE PENALTIES conferred on priests
By this Internal Judiciary
The document goes on to Paragraph 62:
“penalties decreed against priests convicted of the crime of solicitation, with an equal regard for the mind of CANON 2218. . . for estimating the gravity of the crime, -- and their condition, as for example they are minors in age or especially consecrated. . .
64. c: Those who are in danger of falling back into their former ways and therefore becoming greater recidivists should be submitted to particular vigilance.
65. As often as it seems “necessary for the amendment of the delinquent, for the removal of the near occasion of soliciting in the future, or for the prevention of scandal or for the reparation for it, there should be added a prescription for the prohibition of remaining in a certain place.”
This is the part that Boston’s Daniel Shea said lead to the priests being sent places like The Servants of the Paracletes in New Mexico, what Shea described as “vacations"
The more I learn about this whole subject the more it seems it will take a federal RICO (Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act) investigation to bring the whole story out into the open and finally get justice.
=========
More to Come. . .
Sunday, June 3, 2007
Wempe quietly released and living in Leisure World. Cardinal Mahony Hearing Wednesday as Church tries to Quash his Subpoena.
*****
By City of Angels Lady
Call me Scoop. Thursday I interviewed Tony DeMarco on tape then thought the tape did not record. I could not make it play back. This morning I went to find out what happened and the tape played back. So it’s confirmed. Cardinal Roger Mahony was subpoenaed to testify in the Kreutzer Cases trial, and convicted pedophile priest Michael Edwin Wempe, was quietly released recently and is living in Leisure World.
DeMarco said plaintiff “wants to have Cardinal Mahony testify at the June 11th jury trial, re the Kreutzer Cases." He added: "Church lawyers don’t want the Cardinal to testify at trial so they filed a Motion to Quash the Trial Subpoena of the Cardinal.”
In fact the night before May 30th hearing on the Cardinal’s interrogatory answers, plaintiffs "filed an opposition because the Church lawyers filed a Motion to Quash Mr. Brady’s trial subpoena of Cardinal Mahony.” That may explain why church attorneys were distracted and didn't show up for the May 30th hearing.
Plaintiff Attorney Steve J. Brady of San Francisco filed the civil subpoena May 22, arguing "it’s important for the cardinal to be testifying at trial,” DeMarco said.
He added: “I like Mr. Brady’s arguments. I think they had merit.”
The following is copied from Superior Court website:
06/06/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion for Order (QUASHING CIVIL SUBPOENA(PAPERS FILED ON 5/22)RE: BC308065)
So it’s confirmed. The hearing June 6th is regarding Mahony’s testimony.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) As you know City of Angels Blog carries no ads and takes no bribes. Don’t expect much coverage from the LA Times, they're laying off. Although last month ads ran in trade papers for an "experienced celebrity reporter" for the Times’ expanding Entertainment Beat.
Just about the only place you'll find freedom of the press today is in blogs. So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five to five hundred on the Pay-Pal “Make Donation” button. The money goes directly to me, Kay Ebeling, writer of this blog, and I report it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
I’m just not a corporation. I’m keeping alive an old American tradition, passing the hat. If I were a balladeer I’d be on a street corner with my guitar, playing Beatles songs, then passing the hat for dollars and cents. Instead I’m a journalist, this year, so passing the Donate Button after writing coverage of these hearings and trials.
So please put whatever cash you can on my Donate Button in the top left corner of this blog. If 300 people send me five dollars I can cover my rent and bills. Every little bit helps.
Kay Ebeling
END COMMERCIAL BREAK**********
WEMPE Depositions in Progress
Wait. Isn't he still in prison????
DeMarco was rushing Thursday to get to Orange County and depose Michael Edwin Wempe whose jury trial is on calendar for October 9, 2007. “It’s a deposition, not a hearing,” DeMarco explained.
“We sit down, there’s a court reporter present and we ask questions under oath and he has to respond.”
To depose Wempe they have to go to Newport Beach Beach because “That's close to where where he lives,” DeMarco said.
“He lives in Seal Beach if I’m not mistaken Leisure World.”
Okay. . . Wait a minute, isn’t Wempe still in prison?
Here is the Bishop Accountability Dot Org account of Wempe’s career:
“Accused of abuse of 13 from 1972-1995 per archdiocesan report. Sued several times from 2002 to 2003. Original criminal charges dropped due to Supreme Court ruling. Re-arrested 2003. Convicted 1 count 2006. Sentenced to 3 yrs prison in May, 2006. Included in 12/06 $60 mil settlement re 22 priests which covers all of the cases involving molestations that occurred since Mahony was named head of the diocese in 1985.”
They don’t say anything about his getting out of prison.
This was reported January 25.
By Tom Kisken
Ventura County Star [California]
January 25, 2007
http://www.venturacountystar.com/vcs/county_news/article/0,1375,VCS_226_5303761,00.html
The release from prison of a former Roman Catholic priest who served in Ventura County and was convicted of molesting a young boy has been put on hold while state officials evaluate whether he is likely to offend again.
Michael Wempe was due to get out of North Kern State Prison near Bakersfield on Jan. 6. He was sentenced in May to serve three years after a jury found him guilty of a single count of molestation but received credit for time served, prison work and good behavior.
-----
The LA Times reported pretty much the same information on the same date, January 25, 2007, plus this morsel:
http://www.latimes.com/news/printedition/california/la-me-wempe
25jan25,1,385502.story?coll=la-headlines-pe-california
“. . . . Wempe spent 600 days in custody awaiting trial, and had been due for release Jan. 6. His release was delayed for 45 days to allow for an evaluation, according to Bill Sessa, a spokesman for state corrections officials Wempe's lawyer, Leonard Levine, said his client should not face additional punishment."
And back in July 2006 there were reports that other prisoners attacked Wempe, as so often happens to convicted child molesters in prison.
Apparently Wempe was quietly released under the radar, nothing in the Bishop Accountability database or Abuse Tracker so it couldn't have been in the news. . . .
And Wempe is living in Leisure World.
I didn't plan on working today, it being Sunday but there will be
More to Come. . .
By City of Angels Lady
Call me Scoop. Thursday I interviewed Tony DeMarco on tape then thought the tape did not record. I could not make it play back. This morning I went to find out what happened and the tape played back. So it’s confirmed. Cardinal Roger Mahony was subpoenaed to testify in the Kreutzer Cases trial, and convicted pedophile priest Michael Edwin Wempe, was quietly released recently and is living in Leisure World.
DeMarco said plaintiff “wants to have Cardinal Mahony testify at the June 11th jury trial, re the Kreutzer Cases." He added: "Church lawyers don’t want the Cardinal to testify at trial so they filed a Motion to Quash the Trial Subpoena of the Cardinal.”
In fact the night before May 30th hearing on the Cardinal’s interrogatory answers, plaintiffs "filed an opposition because the Church lawyers filed a Motion to Quash Mr. Brady’s trial subpoena of Cardinal Mahony.” That may explain why church attorneys were distracted and didn't show up for the May 30th hearing.
Plaintiff Attorney Steve J. Brady of San Francisco filed the civil subpoena May 22, arguing "it’s important for the cardinal to be testifying at trial,” DeMarco said.
He added: “I like Mr. Brady’s arguments. I think they had merit.”
The following is copied from Superior Court website:
06/06/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion for Order (QUASHING CIVIL SUBPOENA(PAPERS FILED ON 5/22)RE: BC308065)
So it’s confirmed. The hearing June 6th is regarding Mahony’s testimony.
*****Commercial Break*****
KAY: (In NPR Fund Raiser Voice) As you know City of Angels Blog carries no ads and takes no bribes. Don’t expect much coverage from the LA Times, they're laying off. Although last month ads ran in trade papers for an "experienced celebrity reporter" for the Times’ expanding Entertainment Beat.
Just about the only place you'll find freedom of the press today is in blogs. So in that spirit, help keep the City of Angels Blog alive by putting a high five to five hundred on the Pay-Pal “Make Donation” button. The money goes directly to me, Kay Ebeling, writer of this blog, and I report it as freelance income to the IRS, so everything is legal and above board.
I’m just not a corporation. I’m keeping alive an old American tradition, passing the hat. If I were a balladeer I’d be on a street corner with my guitar, playing Beatles songs, then passing the hat for dollars and cents. Instead I’m a journalist, this year, so passing the Donate Button after writing coverage of these hearings and trials.
So please put whatever cash you can on my Donate Button in the top left corner of this blog. If 300 people send me five dollars I can cover my rent and bills. Every little bit helps.
Kay Ebeling
END COMMERCIAL BREAK**********
WEMPE Depositions in Progress
Wait. Isn't he still in prison????
DeMarco was rushing Thursday to get to Orange County and depose Michael Edwin Wempe whose jury trial is on calendar for October 9, 2007. “It’s a deposition, not a hearing,” DeMarco explained.
“We sit down, there’s a court reporter present and we ask questions under oath and he has to respond.”
To depose Wempe they have to go to Newport Beach Beach because “That's close to where where he lives,” DeMarco said.
“He lives in Seal Beach if I’m not mistaken Leisure World.”
Okay. . . Wait a minute, isn’t Wempe still in prison?
Here is the Bishop Accountability Dot Org account of Wempe’s career:
“Accused of abuse of 13 from 1972-1995 per archdiocesan report. Sued several times from 2002 to 2003. Original criminal charges dropped due to Supreme Court ruling. Re-arrested 2003. Convicted 1 count 2006. Sentenced to 3 yrs prison in May, 2006. Included in 12/06 $60 mil settlement re 22 priests which covers all of the cases involving molestations that occurred since Mahony was named head of the diocese in 1985.”
They don’t say anything about his getting out of prison.
This was reported January 25.
By Tom Kisken
Ventura County Star [California]
January 25, 2007
http://www.venturacountystar.com/vcs/county_news/article/0,1375,VCS_226_5303761,00.html
The release from prison of a former Roman Catholic priest who served in Ventura County and was convicted of molesting a young boy has been put on hold while state officials evaluate whether he is likely to offend again.
Michael Wempe was due to get out of North Kern State Prison near Bakersfield on Jan. 6. He was sentenced in May to serve three years after a jury found him guilty of a single count of molestation but received credit for time served, prison work and good behavior.
-----
The LA Times reported pretty much the same information on the same date, January 25, 2007, plus this morsel:
http://www.latimes.com/news/printedition/california/la-me-wempe
25jan25,1,385502.story?coll=la-headlines-pe-california
“. . . . Wempe spent 600 days in custody awaiting trial, and had been due for release Jan. 6. His release was delayed for 45 days to allow for an evaluation, according to Bill Sessa, a spokesman for state corrections officials Wempe's lawyer, Leonard Levine, said his client should not face additional punishment."
And back in July 2006 there were reports that other prisoners attacked Wempe, as so often happens to convicted child molesters in prison.
Apparently Wempe was quietly released under the radar, nothing in the Bishop Accountability database or Abuse Tracker so it couldn't have been in the news. . . .
And Wempe is living in Leisure World.
I didn't plan on working today, it being Sunday but there will be
More to Come. . .
Saturday, June 2, 2007
Coincidence or ? - Public Access to Clergy Case Files Denied Friday. Hearings on Motion to Quash and Motion to Comply with Subpoenas June 6th
*****
By City of Angels Lady
It could have been a coincidence, but yesterday it was impossible to go document diving in the JCCP network provided for free access to the public in Room 106 of Superior Court Los Angeles. Two days earlier I’d written in this blog about reading the documents in descending order -- and yesterday every other function was working in Room 106 except “sort by descending order” in the clergy case documents. I watched people come in and out accessing their civil cases. The only thing the computers would not open was the only way a person can access the thousands of documents for the 500-plus cases working their way through court this year.
So as much as I tried to find out more about Roger Mahony’s possible testimony June 11th, the public access computer would not let me go there. You could get as far as “sort by ascending order” where the documents begin with 2002. Normally one more click and you are looking at the most recently filed documents. There are literally thousands of screens between the first and last documents, so technically the public still has access. I’d just have to scroll through about 30,000 screens until I got to the motions filed in 2007.
At 12:20 PM, the first time the click would not work, I shivered. Two weeks to the day earlier, Friday May 18th in that very room, a guy had stood over my shoulder, indeed was breathing down my neck, as I showed him, “See you click here and it goes to the first document filed, click again and it takes you to the ones from a few days ago.” This kinda creepy guy had barreled into Room 106 a few minutes earlier announcing that no one respected him for trying to be his own lawyer. He struck up a conversation with me and soon was telling me his own experience with a pederast priest and looking over my shoulders to see how I accessed the documents. Now that function I showed him is just the function that won’t work in Room 106 the public access room for civil cases filed in Los Angeles.
I went two flights up and asked the clerks in Judge Fromholz’ Department 20 if they had any idea what was going on. They told me that Thursday “the vendor” out of the blue announced it was doing an “upgrade” on the JCCP Network files, and they were apparently down all that day as well. Now the files appear to be accessible to the public, but they're not. One clerk is mystified. He promises to email the vendor (software geeks in El Segundo, home of Air Force Space Command, once home of Boeing).
I take breaks and return several times to Room 106. At 3:30 there still is no access. So I can’t read the papers filed re Mahony testifying in BC308065, the Kreutzer case with a June 11th jury trial. I know from the witness list I was able to read Wednesday that the cardinal is Number 17 on the plaintiffs’ witness list in that trial.
Hearings next week on Kreutzer and Hagenbach cases
I think the June 6 hearing on Motion for Order Quashing Civil Subpoena in Case BC308065 (same Kreutzer case)
. . . regards Mahony, as the dates coincide with when Mahony would have been served. But since I couldn't access files yesterday, we’ll have to wait until. . . probably June 6th.
City of Angels Lady will do her best to stay on top of this and find out what's really going on. . . .
As for intelligence, if these are dirty tricks. I expected better from the cardinal.
====
Hearings June 5 on Motion to Compel re Deposition Subpoena and June 6 on Motion for Protective Order
Both hearings re a Hagenbach Case
I couldn't access the JCCP Documents, but by typing individual case numbers I could access a short list of documents on individual case files. Re the BC304657 hearings next week I was only able to read the 33 page original complaint filed October 22 2003 by Attorneys Irwin Zalkin & Michael H. Zimmer in San Diego.
Here are some highlights of the Hagenbach case with two hearings next week:
The duties of Father Hagenbach’s employment included teaching “word of God. . .” pastoral services, spiritual care,
“At all times material Hagenbach was a Roman Catholic Priest
Plaintiff in this particular case is “Stephen H Individually.”
1968 through 1978 Hagenbach moved from parish to parish. He was at Holy trinity to 1973, Holy Family in Artesia to 1974, then “Defendant parish 1974 to 1978.”
Plaintiff was an Altar Boy. “Hagenbach regularly took Plaintiff for trips in the rectory car and allowed Plaintiff to steer. While plaintiff was steering the car. . .
“Plaintiff observed Hagenbach having several other altar boys do the same thing while steering his car. . .”
More incidents in the rectory
Last document available in this short list of documents for this Hagenbach case an “ex parte application” re shortening the time for motion for protective order. Second to the last document is “Plaintiff’s Notice of Jury Fee Deposit.”
Hopefully Public Access to the JCCP Documents will be restored next week.
====
Next week’s Calendar of hearings
COPY PASTED from Los Angeles Superior Court website (subject to change)
06/05/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion to Amend (CHERYL BUSER'S COMPLAINT;(PAPERS FILED ON 05-16-07)RE: BC308065)
06/05/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion to Compel (PLAINTIFFS TO RELEASE OF RECORDSJOINDER BY DEFT DOE 1 ON BC308364AND BC307232(PAPERS FILED ON 5/10))
06/05/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion to Compel (PLAINTIFF ARTURO JACKSON TORELEASE OF RECORDS(PAPERS FILED ON 5/23)RE: BC306507)
06/06/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion for Protective Order ((PAPERS FILED ON 5/25)RE: BC304657)
06/06/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion for Summary Judgment (DOE 1(PAPERS FILED 3/26)**OFF CALENDAR**RE: BC304657, BC286703, BC305515,BC307934, BC307949, BC308294,BC308555,)
06/06/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion for Order (QUASHING CIVIL SUBPOENA (PAPERS FILED ON 5/22) RE: BC308065)
06/06/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion to Compel (A NON PARTY TO COMPLY WITHDEPOSITION SUBPOENA(PAPERS FILED ON 5/30)RE: BC304657)
06/07/2007 at 10:30 am in department 322 at 600 South Commonwealth Ave., Los Angeles, CA 90005
Further Proceedings (-Further Briefing re Privacy Rights-)
NOTE: Motions for Summary Judgment on six cases were taken off calendar.
I wonder if I can sit in on the Privacy Rights Briefing.
More to Come. . .
By City of Angels Lady
It could have been a coincidence, but yesterday it was impossible to go document diving in the JCCP network provided for free access to the public in Room 106 of Superior Court Los Angeles. Two days earlier I’d written in this blog about reading the documents in descending order -- and yesterday every other function was working in Room 106 except “sort by descending order” in the clergy case documents. I watched people come in and out accessing their civil cases. The only thing the computers would not open was the only way a person can access the thousands of documents for the 500-plus cases working their way through court this year.
So as much as I tried to find out more about Roger Mahony’s possible testimony June 11th, the public access computer would not let me go there. You could get as far as “sort by ascending order” where the documents begin with 2002. Normally one more click and you are looking at the most recently filed documents. There are literally thousands of screens between the first and last documents, so technically the public still has access. I’d just have to scroll through about 30,000 screens until I got to the motions filed in 2007.
At 12:20 PM, the first time the click would not work, I shivered. Two weeks to the day earlier, Friday May 18th in that very room, a guy had stood over my shoulder, indeed was breathing down my neck, as I showed him, “See you click here and it goes to the first document filed, click again and it takes you to the ones from a few days ago.” This kinda creepy guy had barreled into Room 106 a few minutes earlier announcing that no one respected him for trying to be his own lawyer. He struck up a conversation with me and soon was telling me his own experience with a pederast priest and looking over my shoulders to see how I accessed the documents. Now that function I showed him is just the function that won’t work in Room 106 the public access room for civil cases filed in Los Angeles.
I went two flights up and asked the clerks in Judge Fromholz’ Department 20 if they had any idea what was going on. They told me that Thursday “the vendor” out of the blue announced it was doing an “upgrade” on the JCCP Network files, and they were apparently down all that day as well. Now the files appear to be accessible to the public, but they're not. One clerk is mystified. He promises to email the vendor (software geeks in El Segundo, home of Air Force Space Command, once home of Boeing).
I take breaks and return several times to Room 106. At 3:30 there still is no access. So I can’t read the papers filed re Mahony testifying in BC308065, the Kreutzer case with a June 11th jury trial. I know from the witness list I was able to read Wednesday that the cardinal is Number 17 on the plaintiffs’ witness list in that trial.
Hearings next week on Kreutzer and Hagenbach cases
I think the June 6 hearing on Motion for Order Quashing Civil Subpoena in Case BC308065 (same Kreutzer case)
. . . regards Mahony, as the dates coincide with when Mahony would have been served. But since I couldn't access files yesterday, we’ll have to wait until. . . probably June 6th.
City of Angels Lady will do her best to stay on top of this and find out what's really going on. . . .
As for intelligence, if these are dirty tricks. I expected better from the cardinal.
====
Hearings June 5 on Motion to Compel re Deposition Subpoena and June 6 on Motion for Protective Order
Both hearings re a Hagenbach Case
I couldn't access the JCCP Documents, but by typing individual case numbers I could access a short list of documents on individual case files. Re the BC304657 hearings next week I was only able to read the 33 page original complaint filed October 22 2003 by Attorneys Irwin Zalkin & Michael H. Zimmer in San Diego.
Here are some highlights of the Hagenbach case with two hearings next week:
The duties of Father Hagenbach’s employment included teaching “word of God. . .” pastoral services, spiritual care,
“At all times material Hagenbach was a Roman Catholic Priest
Plaintiff in this particular case is “Stephen H Individually.”
1968 through 1978 Hagenbach moved from parish to parish. He was at Holy trinity to 1973, Holy Family in Artesia to 1974, then “Defendant parish 1974 to 1978.”
Plaintiff was an Altar Boy. “Hagenbach regularly took Plaintiff for trips in the rectory car and allowed Plaintiff to steer. While plaintiff was steering the car. . .
“Plaintiff observed Hagenbach having several other altar boys do the same thing while steering his car. . .”
More incidents in the rectory
Last document available in this short list of documents for this Hagenbach case an “ex parte application” re shortening the time for motion for protective order. Second to the last document is “Plaintiff’s Notice of Jury Fee Deposit.”
Hopefully Public Access to the JCCP Documents will be restored next week.
====
Next week’s Calendar of hearings
COPY PASTED from Los Angeles Superior Court website (subject to change)
06/05/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion to Amend (CHERYL BUSER'S COMPLAINT;(PAPERS FILED ON 05-16-07)RE: BC308065)
06/05/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion to Compel (PLAINTIFFS TO RELEASE OF RECORDSJOINDER BY DEFT DOE 1 ON BC308364AND BC307232(PAPERS FILED ON 5/10))
06/05/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion to Compel (PLAINTIFF ARTURO JACKSON TORELEASE OF RECORDS(PAPERS FILED ON 5/23)RE: BC306507)
06/06/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion for Protective Order ((PAPERS FILED ON 5/25)RE: BC304657)
06/06/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion for Summary Judgment (DOE 1(PAPERS FILED 3/26)**OFF CALENDAR**RE: BC304657, BC286703, BC305515,BC307934, BC307949, BC308294,BC308555,)
06/06/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion for Order (QUASHING CIVIL SUBPOENA (PAPERS FILED ON 5/22) RE: BC308065)
06/06/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
Motion to Compel (A NON PARTY TO COMPLY WITHDEPOSITION SUBPOENA(PAPERS FILED ON 5/30)RE: BC304657)
06/07/2007 at 10:30 am in department 322 at 600 South Commonwealth Ave., Los Angeles, CA 90005
Further Proceedings (-Further Briefing re Privacy Rights-)
NOTE: Motions for Summary Judgment on six cases were taken off calendar.
I wonder if I can sit in on the Privacy Rights Briefing.
More to Come. . .
Friday, June 1, 2007
Mahony on witness stand June 11 sparks outbreak of objections; more Church Attorney Potts vs Judge transcript in LA cases re predator priests
***
By City of Angels Lady
Cardinal Roger Mahony is Number 17 on the Plaintiff’s Witness List filed May 25th for the Paul Kreutzer Cases going to jury trial June 11th. Defendants have Kreutzer as Witness Number 4, then 9 through 21 are monsignors and sisters, so just reading Defendants’ Witness List can be triggering for a survivor.
Mahony’s name as a witness caused some of the disarray in LA Superior Court last week, re the hearing that vanished from the May 30th calendar. Right up to the time court went into session plaintiffs still thought the hearing re Interrogatories 1 through 8 was to go forward. It had been “penned” onto the printed sheet of paper that is taped outside the courtroom listing the order of hearings that day.
Then Plaintiff Attorney Steven J. Brady of San Francisco subpoenaed the cardinal last week to testify on the witness stand in the Kreutzer Cases trial June 11th. While the Cardinal was wondering how to avoid answering written questions in Interrogatories 1 through 8, which he’d been avoiding since August, the man in robes got served.
The Mahony subpoena caused a stream of faxes and arc scar web posts last week as motions to object and statements to support the Mahony subpoena went between attorneys and the courts. As soon as City of Angels can get to Room 106 and read whatever documents are public, you can read a report here.
On the calendar taped outside court May 30th someone official had written in ink: #9, Motion to Compel, Bc307225. The motion had gone off calendar then gone back on, then apparently gone back off again and on again.
(I know from experience that this piece of paper is sacrosanct to the court. Once at the end of the day I took the sheet down and carried it inside to ask a clerk a question. As soon as I entered all three clerks stopped and stared at me mouths open. Then one said, “You took down my calendar,” with total East LA scolding tone. I learned. That sheet of paper taped outside is The Final Calendar For The Record and it’s pristine, to be written on by officials of the court only.)
So that hearing May 30th re Mahony was still on the calendar May 30th, taken off and put back on at the last minute, and no church attorney showed up for it, as apparently church attorneys knew in advance. . . .
================
JOINT EXHIBIT LIST FOR KREUTZER TRIAL:
POTENTIAL EXHIBITS listed for the Kreutzer Cases:
Filed May 25 by Baker Baker Fink et al Church Attorneys and Steven J. Brady Esquire of San Francisco for the Plaintiff, if even a portion of exhibits on the 15-page document get into court, the trial will be eye-opening and educational.
#34: Sentencing transcript for Case No. LA085861 dated March 5, 2002
Convicted of 11 counts of lewd acts with a child in February 2002, Kreutzer got two life terms for crimes committed between 1975 and 1996. The US Supreme Court Stogner Decision reduced Kreutzer’s sentence and he’s due to be released from prison in November 2008.
=======
Let me say that again.
Paul Kreutzer, pederast predator, will be released from prison November 2008
===============
More from Exhibit List
Lots of photographs of the plaintiff from childhood up.
Lots of news articles.
Plaintiff’s Exhibit #73 is “Impact of Sexual Abuse on Children: A review and Synthesis of Existing Literature.”
Exhibit #81 is “Written and Recorded Statement of Paul Kreutzer taken on June 27 2003 by Doug Blades and Harry Thielin (FBI Agents).
Kreutzer now claims he was lying to the FBI to protect one of his victims.
Exhibit #171 - Trauma Recovery Program Booklet
All the way up to #173 - Title re Eccles Property.
Plaintiff’s Exhibit #25 & 26 are photographs of Paul Kreutzer:
#27 Deposition of Paul Kreutzer from April 23 2007
#104 - Excerpts from Preliminary Hearing of (Plaintiff) testimony Pages 5 - 60.
Then “Plaintiff reserves her right to use any exhibits at trial identified or introduced by defendant and to appropriately supplement her exhibit list based on the evidence presented at trial.
-----------
MORE BANTER BETWEEN POTTS AND FROMHOLZ
Picture Potts, this short wiry guy with a face like a wrinkled Alfalfa. He rat-a-tats his words real fast in a kind of gossipy fem tone. For example read this quote like a woman gossiping:
“This opposition was never posted on Case Home Page, but even if it’s correct, they filed this in 2004.”
Potts spews out officious sentences re dates contradicting dates, spurious arguments so filled with obfuscating words probably even the judge misses some of it, but it’s all on the record once he says it. . .
(Transcribed by City of Angels Winging It Transcripts)
JUDGE: Going back to the demurrer what document sta
tes the June 8 order granted?
PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY: Plaintiff’s request to serve denied June 8.
JUDGE: I’m asking Mr. Potts as he says it was misrepresentation of the court.
POTTS: (digging through papers) Your tentative didn't address it one way or the other.
JUDGE: You're not appreciating what I’m saying.
POTTS: Yes sir filed June 11.
JUDGE: In compliance June 8.
=========
On to the next Clergy Case:
More Church Attorney Potts versus Judge Fromholz
JUDGE: Motion to strike and dismiss Archdiocese and St. Sebastian’s School and Parish. Tentative is to deny, overrule and deny. I’ve read all the papers anything to add?
POTTS: (Think of a wrinkled Alfalfa spewing words at fast forward speed) It is undisputed in this order blah-blah-blah certificate of merit before viable revivable window. Robertson versus insurance company “over a limited period over a specific class of person” time limit is of the essence created, time period is jurisdictional requirement --
JUDGE: What case are you reading?
POTTS: Roberts versus Title Insurance 1936
JUDGE: Is this in your paper
POTTS: Yes on Page 3. (goes right on talking)
POTTS: Statute creates right to file complaint within time period. Blah-blah-blah upon expiration of the time period. It’s not a provable defense it’s a waveable defense it’s -- Certificates filed April fifth court ordered that was, uh, uh, not acceptable.
POTTS: (Cont’d:) I’m not even sure about the court’s statement -- then I saw it attached to a motion in opposition to Mr. Baker’s motion. This opposition was never posted on Case Home Page, but even if it’s correct, they filed this in 2004
(Potts seems to have a death wish the way he’s carrying on with the Judge.)
POTTS: (repeating himself again) Certificates of merit filed four months late -
JUDGE: I don't think that's the case. The late filed certificates of merit were approved by another court. I’m sure you would have pointed it out --
POTTS: (read in catty gay-guy voice)Except it wasn’t an issue until now.
JUDGE: -- So thorough is your preparation.
POTTS: -- All I knew was certificate of merit was filed in 2004--
JUDGE: And approved by the court.
That was the tone in court May 3th.
========
To me it looks like Church Attorney Lee Potts is using ramrod tactics, arguing on and on until the opposition is worn down. It’s 20 minutes later and Potts is still talking about certificates of merit filed after filing deadline.
Then Phillip Baker, standing beside Potts, seems to realize he should say something.
More to Come. . .
By City of Angels Lady
Cardinal Roger Mahony is Number 17 on the Plaintiff’s Witness List filed May 25th for the Paul Kreutzer Cases going to jury trial June 11th. Defendants have Kreutzer as Witness Number 4, then 9 through 21 are monsignors and sisters, so just reading Defendants’ Witness List can be triggering for a survivor.
Mahony’s name as a witness caused some of the disarray in LA Superior Court last week, re the hearing that vanished from the May 30th calendar. Right up to the time court went into session plaintiffs still thought the hearing re Interrogatories 1 through 8 was to go forward. It had been “penned” onto the printed sheet of paper that is taped outside the courtroom listing the order of hearings that day.
Then Plaintiff Attorney Steven J. Brady of San Francisco subpoenaed the cardinal last week to testify on the witness stand in the Kreutzer Cases trial June 11th. While the Cardinal was wondering how to avoid answering written questions in Interrogatories 1 through 8, which he’d been avoiding since August, the man in robes got served.
The Mahony subpoena caused a stream of faxes and arc scar web posts last week as motions to object and statements to support the Mahony subpoena went between attorneys and the courts. As soon as City of Angels can get to Room 106 and read whatever documents are public, you can read a report here.
On the calendar taped outside court May 30th someone official had written in ink: #9, Motion to Compel, Bc307225. The motion had gone off calendar then gone back on, then apparently gone back off again and on again.
(I know from experience that this piece of paper is sacrosanct to the court. Once at the end of the day I took the sheet down and carried it inside to ask a clerk a question. As soon as I entered all three clerks stopped and stared at me mouths open. Then one said, “You took down my calendar,” with total East LA scolding tone. I learned. That sheet of paper taped outside is The Final Calendar For The Record and it’s pristine, to be written on by officials of the court only.)
So that hearing May 30th re Mahony was still on the calendar May 30th, taken off and put back on at the last minute, and no church attorney showed up for it, as apparently church attorneys knew in advance. . . .
================
JOINT EXHIBIT LIST FOR KREUTZER TRIAL:
POTENTIAL EXHIBITS listed for the Kreutzer Cases:
Filed May 25 by Baker Baker Fink et al Church Attorneys and Steven J. Brady Esquire of San Francisco for the Plaintiff, if even a portion of exhibits on the 15-page document get into court, the trial will be eye-opening and educational.
#34: Sentencing transcript for Case No. LA085861 dated March 5, 2002
Convicted of 11 counts of lewd acts with a child in February 2002, Kreutzer got two life terms for crimes committed between 1975 and 1996. The US Supreme Court Stogner Decision reduced Kreutzer’s sentence and he’s due to be released from prison in November 2008.
=======
Let me say that again.
Paul Kreutzer, pederast predator, will be released from prison November 2008
===============
More from Exhibit List
Lots of photographs of the plaintiff from childhood up.
Lots of news articles.
Plaintiff’s Exhibit #73 is “Impact of Sexual Abuse on Children: A review and Synthesis of Existing Literature.”
Exhibit #81 is “Written and Recorded Statement of Paul Kreutzer taken on June 27 2003 by Doug Blades and Harry Thielin (FBI Agents).
Kreutzer now claims he was lying to the FBI to protect one of his victims.
Exhibit #171 - Trauma Recovery Program Booklet
All the way up to #173 - Title re Eccles Property.
Plaintiff’s Exhibit #25 & 26 are photographs of Paul Kreutzer:
#27 Deposition of Paul Kreutzer from April 23 2007
#104 - Excerpts from Preliminary Hearing of (Plaintiff) testimony Pages 5 - 60.
Then “Plaintiff reserves her right to use any exhibits at trial identified or introduced by defendant and to appropriately supplement her exhibit list based on the evidence presented at trial.
-----------
MORE BANTER BETWEEN POTTS AND FROMHOLZ
Picture Potts, this short wiry guy with a face like a wrinkled Alfalfa. He rat-a-tats his words real fast in a kind of gossipy fem tone. For example read this quote like a woman gossiping:
“This opposition was never posted on Case Home Page, but even if it’s correct, they filed this in 2004.”
Potts spews out officious sentences re dates contradicting dates, spurious arguments so filled with obfuscating words probably even the judge misses some of it, but it’s all on the record once he says it. . .
(Transcribed by City of Angels Winging It Transcripts)
JUDGE: Going back to the demurrer what document sta
tes the June 8 order granted?
PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY: Plaintiff’s request to serve denied June 8.
JUDGE: I’m asking Mr. Potts as he says it was misrepresentation of the court.
POTTS: (digging through papers) Your tentative didn't address it one way or the other.
JUDGE: You're not appreciating what I’m saying.
POTTS: Yes sir filed June 11.
JUDGE: In compliance June 8.
=========
On to the next Clergy Case:
More Church Attorney Potts versus Judge Fromholz
JUDGE: Motion to strike and dismiss Archdiocese and St. Sebastian’s School and Parish. Tentative is to deny, overrule and deny. I’ve read all the papers anything to add?
POTTS: (Think of a wrinkled Alfalfa spewing words at fast forward speed) It is undisputed in this order blah-blah-blah certificate of merit before viable revivable window. Robertson versus insurance company “over a limited period over a specific class of person” time limit is of the essence created, time period is jurisdictional requirement --
JUDGE: What case are you reading?
POTTS: Roberts versus Title Insurance 1936
JUDGE: Is this in your paper
POTTS: Yes on Page 3. (goes right on talking)
POTTS: Statute creates right to file complaint within time period. Blah-blah-blah upon expiration of the time period. It’s not a provable defense it’s a waveable defense it’s -- Certificates filed April fifth court ordered that was, uh, uh, not acceptable.
POTTS: (Cont’d:) I’m not even sure about the court’s statement -- then I saw it attached to a motion in opposition to Mr. Baker’s motion. This opposition was never posted on Case Home Page, but even if it’s correct, they filed this in 2004
(Potts seems to have a death wish the way he’s carrying on with the Judge.)
POTTS: (repeating himself again) Certificates of merit filed four months late -
JUDGE: I don't think that's the case. The late filed certificates of merit were approved by another court. I’m sure you would have pointed it out --
POTTS: (read in catty gay-guy voice)Except it wasn’t an issue until now.
JUDGE: -- So thorough is your preparation.
POTTS: -- All I knew was certificate of merit was filed in 2004--
JUDGE: And approved by the court.
That was the tone in court May 3th.
========
To me it looks like Church Attorney Lee Potts is using ramrod tactics, arguing on and on until the opposition is worn down. It’s 20 minutes later and Potts is still talking about certificates of merit filed after filing deadline.
Then Phillip Baker, standing beside Potts, seems to realize he should say something.
More to Come. . .
Thursday, May 31, 2007
Rucker pleas for immunity before he talks in deposition; Rucker cases jury trial December 3, 2007
*****
By City of Angels Lady
I’m breathless but have to go for one more Document Dive. At the Bottom of Page one, going down the JCCP documents in descending order, I find this plea re case BC307410 filed 5.23.07. “Motion for protective order and grant of immunity for defendant George Neville Rucker” -- 21 pages. I also have yet to report that Tony DeMarco was on his way to depose Wempe after court yesterday. Plus I found Kreutzer Cases jury instructions, evidence, and lists of witnesses. (See next post.)
The hearing on immunity for Rucker is on calendar for July 10, barring unanticipated date-shuffling. Rucker pleas for immunity as a way of “Protecting him and immunizing him from criminal prosecution. . . .
“In particular Defendant moves (for) Order immunizing him from prosecution for any act of child molestation, sexual abuse of a minor, and any conspiracy to commit or conceal such acts by Defendant or any other person . . .
Rucker asks for immunity re: “Conspiracy to defraud the public, failure to report, aiding and abetting any criminal act, acting as an accessory after the fact as to any criminal act, (any participation in) continuing criminal enterprise in any manner.”
====
(Hmm. What does Mr. Rucker want to say?)
Let Me Interview Him!!!
(Mr. Steier, as I’ve asked you before, set me up in a room with George Neville Rucker and my tape recorder. If he wants to talk, let him talk to me, and so directly confess to all the world through this blog. I’ll interview Mr. Rucker, transcribe it verbatim, and post it here for everyone to read.
(And we can all pass the hot coals* buck up, so to speak. The priests are not the guilty parties here, it’s the bishops and higher. Parishioners should not be paying for settlements, it should come from the Vatican.
(So, please, Mr. Steier, bypass conventional communications and set me up to interview Rucker, or Wempe or Baker or one of your other priest criminal defense clients.
(I’ll get their story out. You can count on that.)
MORE QUOTES FROM THE RUCKER PLEA FOR IMMUNITY
(Copy typing by Kay)
“Defendant does not want any of his testimony in this matter to be available to support either a genuine or false accusation that he committed a crime. At Defendant’s age, the concern is literally one of life and death.
“…Conspiracies alleged to be ongoing.”
In 2002 a Rico act suit was filed alleging “that the Los Angeles Roman catholic Archdiocese is a ‘continuing criminal enterprise’ in violation of federal civil and criminal laws (commonly called the ‘RICO Act’).
“If Defendant (Rucker) were to be charged at any time in the future for a sexual offense not yet committed or alleged, any evidence of the sexual offenses contained in these complaints would be admissible against him. Thus his answers to deposition questions about past acts have a real potential to incriminate him in the future.
“The Fifth Amendment protects Defendant against such use of his testimony. It is clearly not impossible for him to be accused of a criminal act, whether he commits such an offense or not.
“It is important to note that the gravamen of the allegations against him in the overwhelming majority of claims against Defendant in these cases involve alleged lewd touching with the hands, which does not require the ability to…”
(Sorry it gets real sexually graphic in the next sentences. Don’t even want to go there.)
. . . . .
Once a Pedophile Always A Pedophile?
Oh that old wives’ tale, no, not a mantra*
“Indeed Plaintiff, their attorneys, and other advocates have often recited the mantra (sic) ‘Once a pedophile, always a pedophile.’ Without debating the veracity of that cliché, it is clear that one cannot determine that it is impossible for Defendant to be charged with a sexual offense in the future, and that is the standard required by the Supreme Court. . .”
* I wish people with no knowledge of eastern religion would stop co-opting words like mantra. Oh and how about Investment Guru? Really irks my wrath. . .
-----
Document Quotes Continued:
Rucker’s testimony about past acts has “the potential to make Defendant an unwilling witness against himself in any future prosecution for a sexual offense that occurred any time after 1967.”
“Two Motions to Compel Rucker to testify in deposition have been heard, and the court has issued two orders for him to answer certain questions and yet to be propounded ‘follow-up’ questions.
“Defendant submits it will be much more expeditious to grant him immunity from future prosecution related to his testimony, and against use of his testimony in any future prosecution unrelated to his testimony. . . so that these matters may proceed without undue delay.
Signed Donald H. Steier
Guzin & Steier
Attorneys
For Defendant George Neville Rucker
Next blog: Kreutzer Case Exhibits and Witnesses
** Re: Hot Coals:
Romans 12:20-21
“If your enemies are hungry, feed them.
If they are thirsty, give them something to drink.
In doing this, you will heap
burning coals of shame on their heads.”
21 Don’t let evil conquer you, but conquer evil with good
Yay! Flower Power!
More to Come. . .
By City of Angels Lady
I’m breathless but have to go for one more Document Dive. At the Bottom of Page one, going down the JCCP documents in descending order, I find this plea re case BC307410 filed 5.23.07. “Motion for protective order and grant of immunity for defendant George Neville Rucker” -- 21 pages. I also have yet to report that Tony DeMarco was on his way to depose Wempe after court yesterday. Plus I found Kreutzer Cases jury instructions, evidence, and lists of witnesses. (See next post.)
The hearing on immunity for Rucker is on calendar for July 10, barring unanticipated date-shuffling. Rucker pleas for immunity as a way of “Protecting him and immunizing him from criminal prosecution. . . .
“In particular Defendant moves (for) Order immunizing him from prosecution for any act of child molestation, sexual abuse of a minor, and any conspiracy to commit or conceal such acts by Defendant or any other person . . .
Rucker asks for immunity re: “Conspiracy to defraud the public, failure to report, aiding and abetting any criminal act, acting as an accessory after the fact as to any criminal act, (any participation in) continuing criminal enterprise in any manner.”
====
(Hmm. What does Mr. Rucker want to say?)
Let Me Interview Him!!!
(Mr. Steier, as I’ve asked you before, set me up in a room with George Neville Rucker and my tape recorder. If he wants to talk, let him talk to me, and so directly confess to all the world through this blog. I’ll interview Mr. Rucker, transcribe it verbatim, and post it here for everyone to read.
(And we can all pass the hot coals* buck up, so to speak. The priests are not the guilty parties here, it’s the bishops and higher. Parishioners should not be paying for settlements, it should come from the Vatican.
(So, please, Mr. Steier, bypass conventional communications and set me up to interview Rucker, or Wempe or Baker or one of your other priest criminal defense clients.
(I’ll get their story out. You can count on that.)
MORE QUOTES FROM THE RUCKER PLEA FOR IMMUNITY
(Copy typing by Kay)
“Defendant does not want any of his testimony in this matter to be available to support either a genuine or false accusation that he committed a crime. At Defendant’s age, the concern is literally one of life and death.
“…Conspiracies alleged to be ongoing.”
In 2002 a Rico act suit was filed alleging “that the Los Angeles Roman catholic Archdiocese is a ‘continuing criminal enterprise’ in violation of federal civil and criminal laws (commonly called the ‘RICO Act’).
“If Defendant (Rucker) were to be charged at any time in the future for a sexual offense not yet committed or alleged, any evidence of the sexual offenses contained in these complaints would be admissible against him. Thus his answers to deposition questions about past acts have a real potential to incriminate him in the future.
“The Fifth Amendment protects Defendant against such use of his testimony. It is clearly not impossible for him to be accused of a criminal act, whether he commits such an offense or not.
“It is important to note that the gravamen of the allegations against him in the overwhelming majority of claims against Defendant in these cases involve alleged lewd touching with the hands, which does not require the ability to…”
(Sorry it gets real sexually graphic in the next sentences. Don’t even want to go there.)
. . . . .
Once a Pedophile Always A Pedophile?
Oh that old wives’ tale, no, not a mantra*
“Indeed Plaintiff, their attorneys, and other advocates have often recited the mantra (sic) ‘Once a pedophile, always a pedophile.’ Without debating the veracity of that cliché, it is clear that one cannot determine that it is impossible for Defendant to be charged with a sexual offense in the future, and that is the standard required by the Supreme Court. . .”
* I wish people with no knowledge of eastern religion would stop co-opting words like mantra. Oh and how about Investment Guru? Really irks my wrath. . .
-----
Document Quotes Continued:
Rucker’s testimony about past acts has “the potential to make Defendant an unwilling witness against himself in any future prosecution for a sexual offense that occurred any time after 1967.”
“Two Motions to Compel Rucker to testify in deposition have been heard, and the court has issued two orders for him to answer certain questions and yet to be propounded ‘follow-up’ questions.
“Defendant submits it will be much more expeditious to grant him immunity from future prosecution related to his testimony, and against use of his testimony in any future prosecution unrelated to his testimony. . . so that these matters may proceed without undue delay.
Signed Donald H. Steier
Guzin & Steier
Attorneys
For Defendant George Neville Rucker
Next blog: Kreutzer Case Exhibits and Witnesses
** Re: Hot Coals:
Romans 12:20-21
“If your enemies are hungry, feed them.
If they are thirsty, give them something to drink.
In doing this, you will heap
burning coals of shame on their heads.”
21 Don’t let evil conquer you, but conquer evil with good
Yay! Flower Power!
More to Come. . .
Wednesday, May 30, 2007
Mahony’s Hearing Vanishes, Still He May Testify in Kreutzer Cases Jury Trial. Transcript of Potts-Fromholz Banter in Today's Hearings
*****
By City of Angels Lady
The motion to compel Roger Mahony to respond to Interrogatories 1 through 8 “accidentally” fell off calendar this morning, but the Cardinal’s written responses may now be a moot point. Plaintiff Witness Number 17 in the June 11 Jury trial re Paul Kreutzer, Catholic school math teacher/predator, is Cardinal Roger Mahony.
So Roger Mahony may testify on the witness stand in front of a jury in the Kreutzer Cases, trial date June 11th. Katherine Freberg was gracious as she explained the way Mahony’s interrogatories hearing slipped off calendar today as “one of those things that happen.” She’s only been after Mahony’s answers to these eight questions since last August with endless delays, continuances, and non-response answers.
Freberg explained: She’d filed five motions in one day, four of them to continue hearings re Hagenbach cases and one re this Caffoe case and Interrogatories 1 through 8.
Someone somewhere in the Court system made an error and the Mahony hearing got moved off calendar. But sitting outside for a smoke later in the park between the statues of Christopher Columbus and George Washington it hit me.
Why was there no attorney for the church there for the hearing on Mahony's answers to Interrogatories 1 through 8?
If the moving attorney Freberg didn't know the hearing was off calendar, if it was so accidental and sudden, why was there no attorney for the church in court today?
As of 12:30 PM PST today May 30th the hearing is still on calendar at the Los Angeles Superior Court website:
(Copy and pasted here at 12:35:)
“Future Hearings
05/30/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
MOTION - COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES (BY DEFENDAN DOE 1 TO STANDARDIZEDINTERROGATORIES 1-8;cont from 05-16-07;cont to 6/16RE: BC307225;)"
Oh wait there it is, "cont to 6/16" those little words just slipped in there when no one was looking. So we'll probably never find out what happened to Mahony's Phantom Interrogatories 1 through 8 Hearing.
What Mahony avoided answering in writing he will end up saying as soon as June 2007 on the witness stand.
Some direct transcript from today’s several hearings:
Courtesy of City of Angels Winging It Transcription
There were unusually long and involved hearings today re two issues: Sanctions in one case and Demurrer and Motion to Strike in another.
From the hearing on demurrer and motion to strike the judge granted the church’s request but the resulting argument appeared to raise the judge’s blood pressure, understandably:
JUDGE FROMHOLZ: Grant the motion to strike as stated in the written tentative which I’ve provided.
LEE POTTS: With respect to the demurrer --
And he was off.
Hearing on Demurrer (AND MOTION TO STRIKE(PAPERS FILED ON 3/07)**CONT FROM 4/25**RE: BC291179)
(as listed on LA Superior Court website, Case Summaries, Case #JCCP4286)
POTTS: Third paragraph from bottom toward the end of the third line it can be inferred: Successor Judge Fromholz approved under false pretenses.
Judge Fromholz glares at Potts then gives a difficult smile
POTTS: What was presented to this court, that certificate of merit was based on a need to amend ordered by Judge Lager(??)
(someone in Orange County or somewhere). . .
POTTS (cont’d): It’s possible the court may have not dug through its files and found that order, I doubt that was done.
JUDGE FROMHOLZ: (face is red) I understand your point.
POTTS (cont’d): The Court grants the motion to strike then once it’s granted this defendant has been removed from the case. This defendant should be dismissed. Strike the first amendment complaint and grant motion to suppress. Certificates of Merit in 2004, excuse me certificates of corroborative facts --
(Here I hit my b-b-b “hot-key” and “blah-blah-blah” printed out on the screen. I use that hot key a lot during Church Attorney testimony. I mean most of this from Mr. Potts was something I’d have to read later to understand. They already won the motion --)
Personal Aside re Lee Potts:
I was really glad to see him in court today. I was afraid I'd demolished him.
Riding home on Metro one day last month I passed the crumbling remains of a Catholic Church from the city’s founding years, on the near East Side across from Pico House. As we passed I thought of Lee Potts and felt a tinge of guilt because I’d rapped on him in an earlier blog, said he acted like someone with PTSD himself. I was biting my lip as I thought of it, hoping I didn't cause him any problems.
Then last week on The Massage (see bottom of blog re KJLH) the message over and over again was Romans 12 and these verses 19 and 20 have played over and over again in my head.
19Beloved, never avenge yourselves, but leave the way open for [God's] wrath; for it is written, Vengeance is Mine, I will repay (requite), says the Lord.(C)
20But if your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him drink; for by so doing you will heap burning coals upon his head.(D)
Source: Amplified Bible
It’s not my place to do the wrath. Someone Else is taking care of that. Plus I really like that image of burning coals on their heads.
Back to the Today’s Hearing:
About 5 minutes later Potts is still talking:
(By City of Angels Winging It Transcription)
POTTS: Certificates of Corroborate Fact are an entirely different procedure. Not just the compliance with filing part but the court is weighing evidence and making adjudication on the merits. No other court has held that COCFs can be amended. Can you say “Those facts are different, we now have new facts”?
JUDGE: I think it was the statement of location of the witnesses in this order.
POTTS: But--
JUDGE: Excuse me, sir, that's one of the requirements.
Fromholz fixes Potts with a glare and Potts starts stuttering:
POTTS: Um, but again even if it’s a statement of a necessary element this is a judicatory decision . . . they lose. This is a demurrer to the evidence as they used to have in common law days.
JUDGE: But --
POTTS: Court has found insufficient facts to form --
JUDGE: Why can’t it be amended?
POTTS: That's a whole new area opening up that we need to direct.
=======
It went on like that for another five minutes. At one point DeMarco goes through the gate and whispers to the plaintiff attorney (whose name, sorry, I did not get).
The room gets quiet as all attorneys and the judge dig through their six-inch thick document of papers for this case, all of them leafing through the pages at the top.
POTTS: It’s Exhibit 8.
(Extraneous verbiage deleted)
POTTS: June 8 order says denied.
JUDGE: (Throws thick document down behind him) Okay.
Judge Fromholz folds his hands over his mouth and stares into Potts.
JUDGE: I guess it’s a question of whether I can be relied on by the court.
POTTS: The other thing is they're also playing a bait and switch game.
(I’d like to throw up my hands and say I just hit the b-b-b hot key here “blah-blah-blah” but I didn't. I transcribed a whole 8 or more pages of this oratory that will doubtless be useless for future ages.)
(Excess verbiage deleted)
Next Post: Within Next 24 Hours
George Neville Rucker pleads for immunity so he can testify in deposition “so that these matters may proceed without undue delay,” per Donald Steier’s motion. Hearing July 10th.
More to Come. . .
By City of Angels Lady
The motion to compel Roger Mahony to respond to Interrogatories 1 through 8 “accidentally” fell off calendar this morning, but the Cardinal’s written responses may now be a moot point. Plaintiff Witness Number 17 in the June 11 Jury trial re Paul Kreutzer, Catholic school math teacher/predator, is Cardinal Roger Mahony.
So Roger Mahony may testify on the witness stand in front of a jury in the Kreutzer Cases, trial date June 11th. Katherine Freberg was gracious as she explained the way Mahony’s interrogatories hearing slipped off calendar today as “one of those things that happen.” She’s only been after Mahony’s answers to these eight questions since last August with endless delays, continuances, and non-response answers.
Freberg explained: She’d filed five motions in one day, four of them to continue hearings re Hagenbach cases and one re this Caffoe case and Interrogatories 1 through 8.
Someone somewhere in the Court system made an error and the Mahony hearing got moved off calendar. But sitting outside for a smoke later in the park between the statues of Christopher Columbus and George Washington it hit me.
Why was there no attorney for the church there for the hearing on Mahony's answers to Interrogatories 1 through 8?
If the moving attorney Freberg didn't know the hearing was off calendar, if it was so accidental and sudden, why was there no attorney for the church in court today?
As of 12:30 PM PST today May 30th the hearing is still on calendar at the Los Angeles Superior Court website:
(Copy and pasted here at 12:35:)
“Future Hearings
05/30/2007 at 08:31 am in department 20 at 111 North Hill Street, Los Angeles, CA 90012
MOTION - COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES (BY DEFENDAN DOE 1 TO STANDARDIZEDINTERROGATORIES 1-8;cont from 05-16-07;cont to 6/16RE: BC307225;)"
Oh wait there it is, "cont to 6/16" those little words just slipped in there when no one was looking. So we'll probably never find out what happened to Mahony's Phantom Interrogatories 1 through 8 Hearing.
What Mahony avoided answering in writing he will end up saying as soon as June 2007 on the witness stand.
Some direct transcript from today’s several hearings:
Courtesy of City of Angels Winging It Transcription
There were unusually long and involved hearings today re two issues: Sanctions in one case and Demurrer and Motion to Strike in another.
From the hearing on demurrer and motion to strike the judge granted the church’s request but the resulting argument appeared to raise the judge’s blood pressure, understandably:
JUDGE FROMHOLZ: Grant the motion to strike as stated in the written tentative which I’ve provided.
LEE POTTS: With respect to the demurrer --
And he was off.
Hearing on Demurrer (AND MOTION TO STRIKE(PAPERS FILED ON 3/07)**CONT FROM 4/25**RE: BC291179)
(as listed on LA Superior Court website, Case Summaries, Case #JCCP4286)
POTTS: Third paragraph from bottom toward the end of the third line it can be inferred: Successor Judge Fromholz approved under false pretenses.
Judge Fromholz glares at Potts then gives a difficult smile
POTTS: What was presented to this court, that certificate of merit was based on a need to amend ordered by Judge Lager(??)
(someone in Orange County or somewhere). . .
POTTS (cont’d): It’s possible the court may have not dug through its files and found that order, I doubt that was done.
JUDGE FROMHOLZ: (face is red) I understand your point.
POTTS (cont’d): The Court grants the motion to strike then once it’s granted this defendant has been removed from the case. This defendant should be dismissed. Strike the first amendment complaint and grant motion to suppress. Certificates of Merit in 2004, excuse me certificates of corroborative facts --
(Here I hit my b-b-b “hot-key” and “blah-blah-blah” printed out on the screen. I use that hot key a lot during Church Attorney testimony. I mean most of this from Mr. Potts was something I’d have to read later to understand. They already won the motion --)
Personal Aside re Lee Potts:
I was really glad to see him in court today. I was afraid I'd demolished him.
Riding home on Metro one day last month I passed the crumbling remains of a Catholic Church from the city’s founding years, on the near East Side across from Pico House. As we passed I thought of Lee Potts and felt a tinge of guilt because I’d rapped on him in an earlier blog, said he acted like someone with PTSD himself. I was biting my lip as I thought of it, hoping I didn't cause him any problems.
Then last week on The Massage (see bottom of blog re KJLH) the message over and over again was Romans 12 and these verses 19 and 20 have played over and over again in my head.
19Beloved, never avenge yourselves, but leave the way open for [God's] wrath; for it is written, Vengeance is Mine, I will repay (requite), says the Lord.(C)
20But if your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him drink; for by so doing you will heap burning coals upon his head.(D)
Source: Amplified Bible
It’s not my place to do the wrath. Someone Else is taking care of that. Plus I really like that image of burning coals on their heads.
Back to the Today’s Hearing:
About 5 minutes later Potts is still talking:
(By City of Angels Winging It Transcription)
POTTS: Certificates of Corroborate Fact are an entirely different procedure. Not just the compliance with filing part but the court is weighing evidence and making adjudication on the merits. No other court has held that COCFs can be amended. Can you say “Those facts are different, we now have new facts”?
JUDGE: I think it was the statement of location of the witnesses in this order.
POTTS: But--
JUDGE: Excuse me, sir, that's one of the requirements.
Fromholz fixes Potts with a glare and Potts starts stuttering:
POTTS: Um, but again even if it’s a statement of a necessary element this is a judicatory decision . . . they lose. This is a demurrer to the evidence as they used to have in common law days.
JUDGE: But --
POTTS: Court has found insufficient facts to form --
JUDGE: Why can’t it be amended?
POTTS: That's a whole new area opening up that we need to direct.
=======
It went on like that for another five minutes. At one point DeMarco goes through the gate and whispers to the plaintiff attorney (whose name, sorry, I did not get).
The room gets quiet as all attorneys and the judge dig through their six-inch thick document of papers for this case, all of them leafing through the pages at the top.
POTTS: It’s Exhibit 8.
(Extraneous verbiage deleted)
POTTS: June 8 order says denied.
JUDGE: (Throws thick document down behind him) Okay.
Judge Fromholz folds his hands over his mouth and stares into Potts.
JUDGE: I guess it’s a question of whether I can be relied on by the court.
POTTS: The other thing is they're also playing a bait and switch game.
(I’d like to throw up my hands and say I just hit the b-b-b hot key here “blah-blah-blah” but I didn't. I transcribed a whole 8 or more pages of this oratory that will doubtless be useless for future ages.)
(Excess verbiage deleted)
Next Post: Within Next 24 Hours
George Neville Rucker pleads for immunity so he can testify in deposition “so that these matters may proceed without undue delay,” per Donald Steier’s motion. Hearing July 10th.
More to Come. . .
Tuesday, May 29, 2007
Sexual Privacy Rights of Priests and Other Aberrations of the Constitution in LA Civil Cases Against the Roman Catholic Church
***
By City of Angels Lady
For comparison sake, since we spent the day critiquing a Defendant’s motion, now let’s look at the May 18 Plaintiffs' reply brief re privacy objections concerning Franciscan Friars. Document diving I found this pearl, filed by Timothy Hale of Nye, Peabody & Stirling in Santa Barbara.
Saying the Franciscans have “crossed the line of reasonableness in advocating for the privacy rights of pedophile priests,” Hale quotes Church Attorneys for the Franciscans arguing in court:
THE COURT: So pedophilia is protected by the right of privacy?
CHURCH ATTORNEY HELDT: Yes, Sexual behavior --
THE COURT: Of any kind?
HELDT: Well it has to be in a private setting. . .
Church Attorney Logic: You can’t question a priest about his sex activities because they took place “in a private setting.”
I’m curious why Tim Hale is filing this document this month, so breeze to the second to the last page and read:
“This is not ancient history. These are relatively recent events. . . It involved repeated, credible accusations of childhood sexual abuse against a man who, at least as of Father Harris’ deposition in May 2005, was still a Franciscan priest. Yet, according to the Franciscans and their counsel, Father Kain’s privacy rights outweigh the compelling state interest in protecting children from childhood sexual abuse.”
You go, Tim.
More from May 18 Plaintiff’s reply brief re privacy objections
"IV. Conclusion.
"(These lawsuits are) not about, ‘moral vindication’ or 'to enable vigilante action’" as the Franciscans argue.
"It’s about Public Safety. It is about giving parents and families the information that allows them to make informed decisions regarding who poses a risk to their children.
"For too many years such knowledge and such decisions have been concealed by and under the exclusive control of agents of the Roman Catholic Church. The results have been disastrous.”
Yeah, go, Tim.
I go to Bishop Accountability and look under K and don’t find any reports on a Father Kain.
More Document Diving
Oh here’s a good one.
May 2 Church Attorneys Hennigan et al filed a slew of declarations why Monsignor Arthur J. Lirette should not have to testify in deposition. The Plaintiffs motion was granted at the May 16th hearing despite Church Attorney litigation skills displayed below in their own document.
For the record, these are quotes from church attorney Hennigan's “Separate Statement of Questions and Answers in Dispute” opposing Lirette’s deposition arguing for the Defendant. . . .
CHURCH ATTORNEY HABEL: I’ve let this go on too long with the hypotheticals.
DEMARCO: Seeing as we've run across this issue many times before--
HABEL: And do you know what? And frankly--
DEMARCO: I’m not trying to raise my voice. Please ratchet down.
(Tony DeMarco once again the sound and sober voice up against a Church Attorney’s rantings.)
LAY PERSONS NOT ALLOWED TO HAVE OPINION
According to Church Attorney Logic
DEMARCO: (wants to know) why it is a lay witness or a non-expert is forbidden from offering opinion testimony regarding things that might be within their experience. I would love to see some authority to that. In fact, I’m unaware of any authority to that effect.
HABEL: Let me answer that. They can be asked if they have had certain experiences. A lay person can’t be asked their opinion about -- for opinion testimony.
========
Timothy Hale Document To the Franciscans was Addressed
To Coordination Trial Judges Haley Fromholz and Hon. Ronald Sabraw
Saying Franciscans have “crossed the line of reasonableness in advocating for the privacy rights of pedophile priests.”
--------
More Document Diving:
The Church's March Fishing Expedition Produced a Few Plaintiff Cases on Their Snarled Hooks
A few motions to strike and dismiss filed by the church were granted this month because certificates of merit re mental health weren’t filed correctly. This really bugs me because obviously someone with mental health problems is going to have trouble filing certificates of merit correctly.
Maybe I’m naïve.
Filed May One and Signed By Judge
Motion to Quash and Dismiss Case #bc308213
"Plaintiff’s action must be dismissed because the April 9, 2004, certificates were untimely filed," wrote Judge Fromholz.
The March fishing expedition by Church Attorneys where they filed streams of motion to quash and dismiss based on this argument got a few cases thrown out of court. Using cut and paste legal skills Church Attorneys argued in this stream of motions that certificates of merit weren’t filed on time after December 2003 when most the LA cases were opened and put on "fast track."
In this case plaintiff apparently tried in February and April to redo the certificates of merit, but just couldn't get it right. (I know how that is. I sent crumpled and smashed pieces of paper just last April to the IRS.)
========
ONE MORE DEEP BREATH AND ONE MORE DIVE
INTO ONE MORE DOCUMENT
May 1 2007, Defendant Doe 2’s answer to plaintiff’s first amended complaint for BC308297
(This case concerns one female plaintiff and Doe 2 is St. Joseph School, Pomona.)
Defendant denies everything.
The complaint fails in everything
The Doctrine of Church Autonomy, derived from the Religion “Clause of the First Amendment to the United States Constitution bars all of plaintiffs’ claims.”
(It really rankles my tentacles to read this abuse of my American Constitution which I trust and hold dear so much more than I do the thugs who run the Catholic Church.)
========
Several Motions to Strike are also on Calendar for hearing tomorrow.
More to come. . .
By City of Angels Lady
For comparison sake, since we spent the day critiquing a Defendant’s motion, now let’s look at the May 18 Plaintiffs' reply brief re privacy objections concerning Franciscan Friars. Document diving I found this pearl, filed by Timothy Hale of Nye, Peabody & Stirling in Santa Barbara.
Saying the Franciscans have “crossed the line of reasonableness in advocating for the privacy rights of pedophile priests,” Hale quotes Church Attorneys for the Franciscans arguing in court:
THE COURT: So pedophilia is protected by the right of privacy?
CHURCH ATTORNEY HELDT: Yes, Sexual behavior --
THE COURT: Of any kind?
HELDT: Well it has to be in a private setting. . .
Church Attorney Logic: You can’t question a priest about his sex activities because they took place “in a private setting.”
I’m curious why Tim Hale is filing this document this month, so breeze to the second to the last page and read:
“This is not ancient history. These are relatively recent events. . . It involved repeated, credible accusations of childhood sexual abuse against a man who, at least as of Father Harris’ deposition in May 2005, was still a Franciscan priest. Yet, according to the Franciscans and their counsel, Father Kain’s privacy rights outweigh the compelling state interest in protecting children from childhood sexual abuse.”
You go, Tim.
More from May 18 Plaintiff’s reply brief re privacy objections
"IV. Conclusion.
"(These lawsuits are) not about, ‘moral vindication’ or 'to enable vigilante action’" as the Franciscans argue.
"It’s about Public Safety. It is about giving parents and families the information that allows them to make informed decisions regarding who poses a risk to their children.
"For too many years such knowledge and such decisions have been concealed by and under the exclusive control of agents of the Roman Catholic Church. The results have been disastrous.”
Yeah, go, Tim.
I go to Bishop Accountability and look under K and don’t find any reports on a Father Kain.
More Document Diving
Oh here’s a good one.
May 2 Church Attorneys Hennigan et al filed a slew of declarations why Monsignor Arthur J. Lirette should not have to testify in deposition. The Plaintiffs motion was granted at the May 16th hearing despite Church Attorney litigation skills displayed below in their own document.
For the record, these are quotes from church attorney Hennigan's “Separate Statement of Questions and Answers in Dispute” opposing Lirette’s deposition arguing for the Defendant. . . .
CHURCH ATTORNEY HABEL: I’ve let this go on too long with the hypotheticals.
DEMARCO: Seeing as we've run across this issue many times before--
HABEL: And do you know what? And frankly--
DEMARCO: I’m not trying to raise my voice. Please ratchet down.
(Tony DeMarco once again the sound and sober voice up against a Church Attorney’s rantings.)
LAY PERSONS NOT ALLOWED TO HAVE OPINION
According to Church Attorney Logic
DEMARCO: (wants to know) why it is a lay witness or a non-expert is forbidden from offering opinion testimony regarding things that might be within their experience. I would love to see some authority to that. In fact, I’m unaware of any authority to that effect.
HABEL: Let me answer that. They can be asked if they have had certain experiences. A lay person can’t be asked their opinion about -- for opinion testimony.
========
Timothy Hale Document To the Franciscans was Addressed
To Coordination Trial Judges Haley Fromholz and Hon. Ronald Sabraw
Saying Franciscans have “crossed the line of reasonableness in advocating for the privacy rights of pedophile priests.”
--------
More Document Diving:
The Church's March Fishing Expedition Produced a Few Plaintiff Cases on Their Snarled Hooks
A few motions to strike and dismiss filed by the church were granted this month because certificates of merit re mental health weren’t filed correctly. This really bugs me because obviously someone with mental health problems is going to have trouble filing certificates of merit correctly.
Maybe I’m naïve.
Filed May One and Signed By Judge
Motion to Quash and Dismiss Case #bc308213
"Plaintiff’s action must be dismissed because the April 9, 2004, certificates were untimely filed," wrote Judge Fromholz.
The March fishing expedition by Church Attorneys where they filed streams of motion to quash and dismiss based on this argument got a few cases thrown out of court. Using cut and paste legal skills Church Attorneys argued in this stream of motions that certificates of merit weren’t filed on time after December 2003 when most the LA cases were opened and put on "fast track."
In this case plaintiff apparently tried in February and April to redo the certificates of merit, but just couldn't get it right. (I know how that is. I sent crumpled and smashed pieces of paper just last April to the IRS.)
========
ONE MORE DEEP BREATH AND ONE MORE DIVE
INTO ONE MORE DOCUMENT
May 1 2007, Defendant Doe 2’s answer to plaintiff’s first amended complaint for BC308297
(This case concerns one female plaintiff and Doe 2 is St. Joseph School, Pomona.)
Defendant denies everything.
The complaint fails in everything
The Doctrine of Church Autonomy, derived from the Religion “Clause of the First Amendment to the United States Constitution bars all of plaintiffs’ claims.”
(It really rankles my tentacles to read this abuse of my American Constitution which I trust and hold dear so much more than I do the thugs who run the Catholic Church.)
========
Several Motions to Strike are also on Calendar for hearing tomorrow.
More to come. . .
LA Cardinal Mahony's responses are like gangster movie dialogue in civil cases heading for jury trial next month
====================
Pretrial hearing on Mahony's non-answers May 30th
***
By City of Angels Lady
Trying to keep Cardinal Roger Mahony from answering questions in interrogatories, Church Attorneys put forth Orwellian Newspeak full of contradictions, and in one case even blame an inconsistency on a typographical error, in a motion filed May 17 to keep the cardinal from talking. One excuse they make is: “Defendant (Mahony) stands by those responses already given.” As posted here April 16th, Mahony’s answer to almost every question in interrogatories so far has been:
“Responding party objects to this request. It’s broad, burdensome, harassing, not relevant. Violates religion clause of First Amendment, physician patient privilege, lawyer client privilege, and work product doctrine.”
Now LA’s noble Cardinal “Stands by those responses”? Is he standing, or is he bent over falling down and finally landing flat on his face?
Another excuse put forth by Church Attorneys:
“Defendant’s investigation is ongoing and it does reserve the right to supplement its responses.”
What investigation?
If they’d conducted an investigation decades ago this entire imbroglio would not even be happening today. (And a lot of people like me would be functioning much better.)
More Ways To Keep Mahony from Talking
(NOTE: All these quotes from Defendant Archdiocese can be read out loud using a B-Movie Gangster voice.)
“Defendant concedes that it has been slow to get Plaintiffs the verification; however, Defendant has never refused to provide one.”
That’s great. They've postponed and postulated all over the place to keep Mahony from responding but they never came right out and said they refuse to answer.
And then this double-speak wherein the church explains why a report was in one file and then not in another one. Blame it on a typographical error:
"In its ongoing investigation Defendant located another report that it needs to include in its responses. Defendant preferred to verify the supplemental set that removed the typographical error and included the additional report.”
Huh?
All the quotes from this May 17 motion in opposition to the Plaintiffs motion to compel can be read in a b-movie ganster dialogue voice. Try it: "Defendant concedes that it has been slow to get Plaintiffs the verification; however, Defendant has never refused to provide one.”
==========
They give these excuses for non-response regarding specific priests:
Re: Father John Lenihan:
He was a priest with the Orange Diocese, not Los Angeles.
(They still call these guys Father????? Well they sure can’t say “Most Reverent.”)
Re: Father Lynn Caffoe
Defendant did not include Father Caffoe as information pertaining to the 1975 incident was included in response to Interrogatory 9.
RE: Paul Kreutzer
“Sister Francis is deceased and therefore cannot be interviewed.”
Father John Kenney
Father Christopher to whom the report was made: “has not been in the Archdiocese of Los Angeles for over 20 years.”
(Sure and they have no idea where he is now. . .Where do they send his checks?)
Father Thomas Havel
“A report was allegedly made to a Father Michael Smith who is deceased.” (Like Sister Francis, "deceased and therefore cannot be interviewed.)
(Oh is that why the church is taking so long? They're waiting for all the witnesses to die before they get deposed.)
Re: Father Llanos:
Defendant disputes this report was made. Further, the alleged report was not even made by the plaintiff himself but is based on multiple levels of hearsay.
(That report wasn’t made. And it was made to a different person.)
This tag line is at the end of each one of these priest entries:
“Defendant does not have a duty to admit that a report was made just because a Plaintiff alleges the same in an interrogatory response.”
Can’t you just hear that on a junior high school playground, like a chant?
I don't have to tell you that,
Just because you asked me.
Nyah, nyah, nyah, nyah, nyah.
The Biggest Excuse Of All:
Priests' Right To a Private Sex Life?
Church Attorneys say priests should have the same rights of sexual privacy as plaintiffs.
“Plaintiff objects (to questions of sexual history) because it seeks to obtain information which is not relevant, nor likely to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence.”
That's true if you're talking about investigating the plaintiffs’ private sex lives, not the defendant’s.
More ways to keep Mahony from talking
You'll laugh out loud when you read this in a Tony Soprano b-movie from the 1950s voice:
“Defendant concedes that it has been slow to get Plaintiffs the verification; however, Defendant has never refused to provide one.”
In other words: I know you've been trying to get these answers since last summer but just because we haven’t answered yet doesn't mean we ever refused to answer. . . .
Was it a typo, a filing error, or just a lot of double speak?
Their way of explaining how a report showed up in a second version of a document and not the first:
"In its ongoing investigation Defendant located another report that it needs to include in its responses. Defendant preferred to verify the supplemental set that removed the typographical error and included the additional report.”
Oh that's where it came from,
(All of this weak defense could be called “passive aggressive”: saying you mean to do one thing while you are doing another.)
“Defendant will provide a verification and “recognizes that this should have been done more promptly.”
Just like they never really refused to provide a verification they just kept not giving one.
We’ll see what happens in the hearing tomorrow
NEXT BLOG: You can’t question a priest about his sex life because obviously sexual activities “took place in a private setting.”
QUOTES IN MAY 28 BLOG are from Motion filed May 17, 2007, by Kneafsey Tostado Church Attorneys: “Defendant’s Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion to Compel Interrogatories”
******
Like what you read here? Send me a high five. Click on the Donate button in the top left corner and send five or fifty or five hundred or. . .
Pretrial hearing on Mahony's non-answers May 30th
***
By City of Angels Lady
Trying to keep Cardinal Roger Mahony from answering questions in interrogatories, Church Attorneys put forth Orwellian Newspeak full of contradictions, and in one case even blame an inconsistency on a typographical error, in a motion filed May 17 to keep the cardinal from talking. One excuse they make is: “Defendant (Mahony) stands by those responses already given.” As posted here April 16th, Mahony’s answer to almost every question in interrogatories so far has been:
“Responding party objects to this request. It’s broad, burdensome, harassing, not relevant. Violates religion clause of First Amendment, physician patient privilege, lawyer client privilege, and work product doctrine.”
Now LA’s noble Cardinal “Stands by those responses”? Is he standing, or is he bent over falling down and finally landing flat on his face?
Another excuse put forth by Church Attorneys:
“Defendant’s investigation is ongoing and it does reserve the right to supplement its responses.”
What investigation?
If they’d conducted an investigation decades ago this entire imbroglio would not even be happening today. (And a lot of people like me would be functioning much better.)
More Ways To Keep Mahony from Talking
(NOTE: All these quotes from Defendant Archdiocese can be read out loud using a B-Movie Gangster voice.)
“Defendant concedes that it has been slow to get Plaintiffs the verification; however, Defendant has never refused to provide one.”
That’s great. They've postponed and postulated all over the place to keep Mahony from responding but they never came right out and said they refuse to answer.
And then this double-speak wherein the church explains why a report was in one file and then not in another one. Blame it on a typographical error:
"In its ongoing investigation Defendant located another report that it needs to include in its responses. Defendant preferred to verify the supplemental set that removed the typographical error and included the additional report.”
Huh?
All the quotes from this May 17 motion in opposition to the Plaintiffs motion to compel can be read in a b-movie ganster dialogue voice. Try it: "Defendant concedes that it has been slow to get Plaintiffs the verification; however, Defendant has never refused to provide one.”
==========
They give these excuses for non-response regarding specific priests:
Re: Father John Lenihan:
He was a priest with the Orange Diocese, not Los Angeles.
(They still call these guys Father????? Well they sure can’t say “Most Reverent.”)
Re: Father Lynn Caffoe
Defendant did not include Father Caffoe as information pertaining to the 1975 incident was included in response to Interrogatory 9.
RE: Paul Kreutzer
“Sister Francis is deceased and therefore cannot be interviewed.”
Father John Kenney
Father Christopher to whom the report was made: “has not been in the Archdiocese of Los Angeles for over 20 years.”
(Sure and they have no idea where he is now. . .Where do they send his checks?)
Father Thomas Havel
“A report was allegedly made to a Father Michael Smith who is deceased.” (Like Sister Francis, "deceased and therefore cannot be interviewed.)
(Oh is that why the church is taking so long? They're waiting for all the witnesses to die before they get deposed.)
Re: Father Llanos:
Defendant disputes this report was made. Further, the alleged report was not even made by the plaintiff himself but is based on multiple levels of hearsay.
(That report wasn’t made. And it was made to a different person.)
This tag line is at the end of each one of these priest entries:
“Defendant does not have a duty to admit that a report was made just because a Plaintiff alleges the same in an interrogatory response.”
Can’t you just hear that on a junior high school playground, like a chant?
I don't have to tell you that,
Just because you asked me.
Nyah, nyah, nyah, nyah, nyah.
The Biggest Excuse Of All:
Priests' Right To a Private Sex Life?
Church Attorneys say priests should have the same rights of sexual privacy as plaintiffs.
“Plaintiff objects (to questions of sexual history) because it seeks to obtain information which is not relevant, nor likely to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence.”
That's true if you're talking about investigating the plaintiffs’ private sex lives, not the defendant’s.
More ways to keep Mahony from talking
You'll laugh out loud when you read this in a Tony Soprano b-movie from the 1950s voice:
“Defendant concedes that it has been slow to get Plaintiffs the verification; however, Defendant has never refused to provide one.”
In other words: I know you've been trying to get these answers since last summer but just because we haven’t answered yet doesn't mean we ever refused to answer. . . .
Was it a typo, a filing error, or just a lot of double speak?
Their way of explaining how a report showed up in a second version of a document and not the first:
"In its ongoing investigation Defendant located another report that it needs to include in its responses. Defendant preferred to verify the supplemental set that removed the typographical error and included the additional report.”
Oh that's where it came from,
(All of this weak defense could be called “passive aggressive”: saying you mean to do one thing while you are doing another.)
“Defendant will provide a verification and “recognizes that this should have been done more promptly.”
Just like they never really refused to provide a verification they just kept not giving one.
We’ll see what happens in the hearing tomorrow
NEXT BLOG: You can’t question a priest about his sex life because obviously sexual activities “took place in a private setting.”
QUOTES IN MAY 28 BLOG are from Motion filed May 17, 2007, by Kneafsey Tostado Church Attorneys: “Defendant’s Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion to Compel Interrogatories”
******
Like what you read here? Send me a high five. Click on the Donate button in the top left corner and send five or fifty or five hundred or. . .
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
